Show all abstracts
View Session
- Front Matter: Volume 6924
- Keynote Session
- Double Masking I
- Double Masking II
- Low-k1 Lithography I
- Low-k1 Lithography II
- Double Masking III
- Simulation I
- Simulation II
- High Index Immersion Lithography
- Process I
- OPC and Mask Technology
- Process II
- Lithography Tools I
- Lithography Tools II
- Poster Session: Double Masking
- Poster Session: High Index Immersion Lithography
- Poster Session: Lithography Tools
- Poster Session: Low-k1 Lithography
- Poster Session: OPC and Mask Technology
- Poster Session: Process
- Poster Session: Simulation
Front Matter: Volume 6924
Front Matter: Volume 6924
Show abstract
This PDF file contains the front matter associated with SPIE
Proceedings Volume 6924, including the Title Page, Copyright
information, Table of Contents, Introduction (if any), and the
Conference Committee listing.
Keynote Session
If it moves, simulate it!
Show abstract
In the last 35 years modeling of projection printing has undergone many paradigm shifts in physical models,
computational engines, algorithms and opportunities. The trigger event for the first quantitative positive resist Dill model
was the development and application of automated thin-film measurement equipment. The use of partial coherence
which helps imaging also complicates the understanding and necessitates the use of simulation to guide lithography
practice. Simulation has also played an important role in discovery (intensity imbalance in phase-shifting masks),
invention (self-interferometric mask monitors) and creation of analysis techniques (first-cut accurate fast-CAD). The
current challenges and growth areas for simulation include calibration, synergy with metrology, electronic self-testing
and linking circuit design and fabrication.
Interactions of double patterning technology with wafer processing, OPC and design flows
Show abstract
Double patterning technology (DPT) is one of the main options for printing logic devices with half-pitch
less than 45nm; and flash and DRAM memory devices with half-pitch less than 40nm. DPT methods
decompose the original design intent into two individual masking layers which are each patterned using
single exposures and existing 193nm lithography tools. The results of the individual patterning layers
combine to re-create the design intent pattern on the wafer. In this paper we study interactions of DPT with
lithography, masks synthesis and physical design flows. Double exposure and etch patterning steps create
complexity for both process and design flows. DPT decomposition is a critical software step which will be
performed in physical design and also in mask synthesis. Decomposition includes cutting (splitting) of
original design intent polygons into multiple polygons where required; and coloring of the resulting
polygons. We evaluate the ability to meet key physical design goals such as: reduce circuit area; minimize
rework; ensure DPT compliance; guarantee patterning robustness on individual layer targets; ensure
symmetric wafer results; and create uniform wafer density for the individual patterning layers.
Toward 3nm overlay and critical dimension uniformity: an integrated error budget for double patterning lithography
Show abstract
Double patterning has emerged as the likely lithography technology to bridge the gap between water-based ArF
immersion lithography and EUV. The adoption of double patterning is driven by the accelerated timing of the
introduction of device shrinks below 40nm half pitch, especially for NAND flash. With scaling, increased device
sensitivity to parameter variations puts extreme pressure on controlling overlay and critical dimension uniformity.
Double patterning also makes unique demands on overlay and CDU. Realizing that there is no further increase in NA
past the current 1.35 on the horizon, the focus has shifted from a straight shrink using the newest tool to learning how to
reduce the effective k1 through improvements to the tool's control of CDU and overlay, as well as innovative RET,
mask, and process technology.
In double patterning lithography, CDU and overlay are complex and entangled errors. In an approach where the pattern
is split into two masks and recombined in successive lithography and etch steps, a line or space width is defined by
edges placed at separate masks. In an approach where double patterning is achieved by self-aligned processes, CD error
at the first sacrificial mask will translate into pattern placement errors in the final pattern. In all approaches, it is crucial
to understand how these errors interact so that the combined effects can be minimized through proper tool controls,
mask OPC and split algorithms, and process choices. Without aggressive actions, the complexity of this problem
combined with the economic drawbacks of using multiple masking steps to define critical device layers threaten to slow
overall device shrink rates.
This paper will explore the main sources of critical dimension and overlay errors in double patterning lithography and
will point out directions we may follow to make this an effective manufacturing solution.
Double Masking I
A study of CD budget in spacer patterning technology
Show abstract
We constructed CD budget for spacer patterning technology which is one of the strongest candidates in double
patterning technologies for below 3x nm half pitch generations. In the CD budgeting, three patterning portions of grid
patterns should be considered, namely, "line", "paired space" and "adjoined space", because they have individual
process error sources that affect CD variations. Analysis of the patterning process flow revealed that the amount of CD
variations for positive type spacer patterning technology was in the order of "adjoined space" > "paired space" > "line".
Also, the experimental verifications in CD variations substantiated the constructed CD budget. From the viewpoint of
design for manufacturability (DfM), these process features should be taken into account in the device engineering.
Therefore, for the successful implementation of spacer patterning technology into high-end devices, we propose a cross-
functional development scheme encompassing device technologies and process technologies using the constructed CD
budget.
Double patterning for 32nm and below: an update
Show abstract
Double patterning lithography - either with two litho and etch steps or through the use of a sacrificial spacer layer, have
equal complexity and particularly tight requirements on CDU and Overlay. Both techniques pose difficult challenges to
process control, metrology and integration, but seem feasible for the 32nm node.
In this paper, we report results in exploring CDU and overlay performance at 32nm 1/2 pitch resolution of two double
patterning technology options, Dual Photo Etch, LELE and sidewall spacer with sacrificial layer. We discuss specific
aspects of CD control present in any double patterning lithography, the existence of multiple populations of lines and
spaces, with overlay becoming part of CDU budget. The existence of multiple and generally uncorrelated CD
populations, demands utilization of full field and full wafer corrections to bring together the CDU of these multiple
populations in order to meet comparable 10% CDU as in single exposure.
We present experimental results of interfield and intrafield CD and overlay statistical and spatial distributions confirming
capability to improve these distributions to meet dimensional and overlay control levels required by 32nm node. After
compensation, we achieved a CDU control for each population, of 2nm or better and 3nm overlay on multiple wafers and
multiple state of art, hyper NA immersion scanners. Results confirmed our assumptions for existence of multiple CDU
populations entangled overlay into CDU.
Split and design guidelines for double patterning
Show abstract
Double Patterning is investigated at IMEC as a timely solution to meet the 32nm node requirements. It further extends
the use of water immersion lithography at its maximum numerical aperture NA=1.35. The aim of DP is to make dense
features possible by splitting a design into two more sparse designs and by recombining into the target pattern through a
double patterning flow (stitching). Independently of the implementation by the EDA vendors and designers, we discuss
some guidelines for split and for DP-compliant design to ensure a robust stitching through process variations. We focus
more specifically on the first metal interconnect patterning layer (metal1) for random logic applications. We use both
simulations and experiments to study the patterning of 2D split test patterns varied in a systematic way.
Double Masking II
Double patterning combined with shrink technique to extend ArF lithography for contact holes to 22nm node and beyond
Show abstract
Lithography becomes much more challenging when CD shrinks to 22nm nodes. Since EUV is not ready, double
patterning combined with Resolution Enhancement Technology (RET) such as shrink techniques seems to be the most
possible solution. Companies such as TSMC[1] and IBM[2] etc. are pushing out EUV to extend immersion ArF
lithography to 32nm/22nm nodes.
Last year, we presented our development work on 32nm node contact (50nm hole at 100nm pitch) using dry ArF
lithography by double patterning with SAFIER shrink process[3]. To continue the work, we further extend our dry litho
capability towards the 22nm node. We demonstrated double patterning capability of 40nm holes at 80nm pitch using
ASML XT1400E scanner. It seems difficult to print pitches below 140nm on dry scanner in single exposure which is
transferred into 70nm pitch with double patterning.
To push the resolution to 22nm node and beyond, we developed ArF immersion process on ASML XT1700i-P system at
the College of Nanoscale Science and Engineering (Albany, NY) combined with a SAFIER process. We achieved single
exposure process capability of 25nm holes at 128nm pitch after shrink. It enables us to print ~25nm holes at pitch of
64nm with double patterning.
Two types of hard mask (HM), i.e. TIN and a-Si were used in both dry and immersion ArF DP processes. The double
patterning process consists of two HM litho-shrink-etch steps. The dense feature is designed into two complementary
parts on two masks such that the density is reduced by half and minimum pitch is increased by at least a factor of 21/2
depending on design. The complete pattern is formed after the two HM litho-shrink-etch steps are finished.
Negative and iterated spacer lithography processes for low variability and ultra-dense integration
Show abstract
Variation in the critical dimension (CD) of a transistor is a primary concern for advanced lithography. Because
variation from sources such as corner rounding or line edge roughness does not scale with CD, variability in transistor
performance increases with scaling and may impact the timing or even the functionality of critical circuits such as static
random access memories (SRAM) and ring oscillators. Spacer lithography is an attractive patterning method for future
technology nodes, because its use of a very uniform and controllable chemical vapor deposition (CVD) step allows for
the definition of very narrow lines with low variation and reduced pitch1,2. In practice, however, the possible pitch
reductions are limited by the need for conventional lithography to produce negative features (e.g., trenches and holes)
and increasing CD variability with iterated spacer processing. In this work, an extension to spacer lithography is
presented to overcome these limitations. Negative features down to 30nm in width are fabricated using spacer-defined
features. A multi-tiered hard mask process is also presented to enable eight-fold pitch reduction with no increase in CD
variation. In combination, these processes enable ultra-dense circuit integration for regular layouts.
Double patterning of contact array with carbon polymer
Show abstract
The spacer patterning technique (SPT) is well known as one of the methods expanding the resolution limit and mainly
useful for patterning line & space of memory device. Although contact array could be achieved by both spacer patterning
technique and double exposure & etch technique (DEET) 1, the former would be preferable to the latter by the issues of
overlay burden and resolution limit of isolated contact. The process procedure for contact array is similar to that for line
& space which involves the 1st mask exposure, etch, carbon polymer deposition, the 2nd mask exposure and etch step
sequentially. With SPT, it would be possible to realize contact array of 30nm half pitch including 30nm isolated contact
as well as line & space of 30nm half pitch.
PDL oxide enabled pitch doubling
Show abstract
A double patterning (DP) process is introduced with application for advanced technology nodes. This DP technique is enabled by a novel low-temperature pulsed deposition layer (PDLTM) oxide film which is deposited directly on patterned photoresist. In this article, we will report the results of fabrication of sub-50nm features on a 100nm pitch by the PDL-spacer DP process using 0.85 NA dry ArF lithography. This result represents the potential of the PDL-based DP to significantly enhance the resolution of the patterning process beyond the limits of optical lithography. Components of CD variance for this spacer DP scheme will be discussed.
Low-k1 Lithography I
Pixelated phase mask as novel lithography RET
Show abstract
Novel RET-Pixelated Phase Mask (PPM) is proposed as a novel Resolution Enhancement Technique (RET). PPM is
made of pixels of various phases with lateral dimensions significantly smaller than the illuminating radiation
wavelength. Such PPM with a singular choice of pixel dimensions acts as a mask with variable phase and transmission
due to radiation scattering and attenuation on pixel features with the effective intensity and phase modulated by the
pixel layout. Key properties of the pixelated phase masks, the steps for their practical realization, and the benefits to
random logic products discussed. Wafer patterning performance and comparative functional yield results obtained for a
65nm node microprocessor patterned with PPM, as well as current PPM limitations are also presented.
Mask optimization for arbitrary patterns with 2D-TCC resolution enhancement technique
Show abstract
In this paper, a new resolution enhancement technique named 2D-TCC technique is proposed. This method can
enhance resolution of line patterns as well as that of contact hole patterns by the use of an approximate aerial image.
The aerial image, which is obtained by 2D-TCC calculation, expresses the degree of coherence at the image plane of a
projection optic considering mask transmission at the object plane. OPC of desired patterns and placement of assist
patterns can be simultaneously performed according to an approximate aerial image called a 2D-TCC map. Fast
calculation due to truncation of a series in calculating an aerial image is another advantage. Results of mask
optimization for various line patterns and the validity of the 2D-TCC technique by simulations and experiments are
reported.
Comparative study of binary intensity mask and attenuated phase shift mask using hyper-NA immersion lithography for sub-45nm era
Show abstract
In this paper, we will present comparison of attenuated phase shift mask and binary intensity mask at hyper-NA
immersion scanner which has been the main stream of DRAM lithography. Some technical issues will be reported for
polarized illumination in hyper-NA imaging. One att.PSM (Phase Shift Mask) and three types of binary intensity mask
are used for this experiment; those are ArF att.PSM ( MoSi:Å ), thick Cr ( 1030Å ) BIM (Binary Intensity Mask),
thin Cr ( 590Å ) BIM and multi layer ( Cr:740Å / MoSi:930Å ) BIM. Simulation and experiment with 1.35NA
immersion scanner are performed to study influence of mask structure, process margin and effect of polarization. Two
types of DRAM cell patterns are studied; one is an isolation pattern with a brick wall shape and another is a storage node
pattern with contact hole shape. Line and space pattern is also studied through 38nm to 50nm half pitch for this
experiment. Lithography simulation is done by in-house tool based on diffused aerial image model. EM-SUITE is also
used in order to study the influence of mask structure and polarization effect through rigorous EMF simulation.
Transmission and polarization effects of zero and first diffraction order are simulated for both att.PSM and BIM. First
and zero diffraction order polarization are shown to be influenced by the structure of masking film. As pattern size on
mask decreases to the level of exposure wavelength, incident light will interact with mask pattern, and then transmittance
changes for mask structure. Optimum mask bias is one of the important factors for lithographic performance. In the case
of att.PSM, negative bias shows higher image contrast than positive one, but in case of binary intensity mask, positive
bias shows better performance than negative one. This is caused by balance of amplitude between first diffraction order
and zero diffraction order light.
Process windows and mask error enhancement factors are measured with respect to various design rules, i.e., different k1
levels at fixed NA. In the case of one dimensional line and space pattern, thick Cr BIM shows the best performance
through various pitches. But in case of two dimensional DRAM cell pattern, it is difficult to find out the advantage of
BIM for sub-45nm. It needs further study for two dimensional patterns. Finally, it was observed that thick Cr binary
intensity mask for sub-45nm has advantage for one dimensional line and space pattern.
Low-k1 Lithography II
Integration of pixelated phase masks for full-chip random logic layers
Show abstract
This work describes the advantages, tolerances and integration issues of using Pixelated Phase Masks for patterning
logic interconnect layers. Pixelated Phase Masks (PPMs) can act as variable high-transmission attenuated phase shift
masks where the pixelated phase configuration simultaneously optimizes OPC and SRAF generation. Thick mask
effects help enable PPMs by allowing larger minimum pixel sizes and phase designs with near equal sized zero and piphase
regions. PPMs with a 3-tone pixel mask (un-etched glass, etched glass, chrome) offer more flexible patterning
capability compared to 2-tone pixel mask (no chrome) style but at the detriment of a more complex mask making
process. We describe the issues and opportunities associated with using PPMs for patterning a 65nm generation first
level metal layer of a micro-processor.
Applications of TM polarized illumination
Show abstract
The use of transverse electric (TE) polarization has dominated illumination schemes as selective polarization is
used for high-NA patterning. The benefits of TE polarization are clear - the interference of diffracted beams remains
absolute at oblique angles. Transverse magnetic (TM) polarization is usually considered less desirable as imaging
modulation from interference at large angle falls off rapidly as the 1/cosθ. Significant potential remains, however, for
the use of TM polarization at large angles when its reflection component is utilized. By controlling the resist/substrate
interface reflectivity, high modulation for TM polarization can be maintained for angles up to 90° in the resist. This can
potentially impact the design of illumination away from most recent TE-only schemes for oblique imaging angles (high
NA). We demonstrate several cases of TM illumination combined with tuned substrate reflectivity for 0.93NA, 1.20NA,
and 1.35NA and compare results to TE and unpolarized cases. The goal is to achieve a flat response through polarization
at large imaging angles.
An additional application of TM illumination is its potential use for double patterning. As double patterning
and double exposure approaches are sought in order to meet the needs of 32nm device generations and beyond, materials
and process engineering challenges become prohibitive. We have devised a method for frequency doubling in a single
exposure using an unconventional means of polarization selection and by making use of the reflective component
produced at the photoresist/substrate interface. In doing so, patterns can be deposited into a photoresist film with double
density. As an example, using a projection system numerical aperture of 1.20, with water as an immersion fluid, and a
conventional polyacrylate 193nm photoresist, pattern resolution at 20nm half-pitch are obtainable (which is
0.125lambda/NA). The process to transfer this geometry into a hardmask layer uses conventional materials, including
the photoresist layer and thin film silicon oxide based materials.
Enabling technology scaling with "in production" lithography processes
Show abstract
As the industry hits a road block with RETs that attempt to aggressively scale k1, we propose to extend the life of optical
lithography by a complete co-optimization between circuit choices, layout patterns and lithography. We demonstrate that
the judicious selection of a small number of layout patterns along with the appropriate circuit topologies would not only
enable k1 relaxation but also efficient implementation of circuits. Additionally, in this paper, we discuss the use of
regular design fabrics to extend the life of current generation lithography equipment. We will introduce the Front End of
Line (FEOL) limited regular design fabric. The metal 1 patterns for this fabric are selected such that we can utilize a 1.2
NA 32nm metal 1 lithography process without any area penalty with respect to standard cells with conventional design
rules, which require a 32nm metal 1 process with a rather unrealistic k1 of 0.35 while using a more advanced 1.35 NA
tool. We also demonstrate simulation results on 2-dimensional layout patterns. The results suggest that smart selection of
layout patterns can enable the extension of single exposure lithography to a 32nm production lithography process.
Hyper-NA imaging of 45nm node random CH layouts using inverse lithography
Show abstract
The imaging of Contact Hole (CH) layouts is one of the most challenging tasks in hyper-NA lithography. Contact Hole
layouts can be printed using different illumination conditions, but an illumination condition that provides good imaging
at dense pitches (such as Quasar or Quadrupole illumination), will usually suffer from poor image contrast and Depth of
Focus (DOF) towards the more isolated pitches. Assist Features (AF) can be used to improve the imaging of more
isolated contact holes, but for a random CH layout, an AF placement rule would have to be developed for every CH
configuration in the design. This makes optimal AF placement an almost impossible task for random layouts when using
rule-based AF placement. We have used an inverse lithography technique by Mentor Graphics, to treat a random contact
hole layout (drawn at minimal pitch 115nm) for imaging at NA 1.35. The combination of the dense 115nm pitch and
available NA of 1.35 makes the use of Quasar illumination necessary, and the treatment of the clip with inverse
lithography automatically generated optimal (model-based) AF for all geometries in the design. Because the inverse
lithography solution consists of smooth shapes rather than rectangles, mask manufacturability becomes a concern. The
algorithm allows simplification of the smooth shapes into rectangles and greatly improves mask write time. Wafer prints
of clips treated with inverse lithography at NA 1.35 confirm the benefit of the assist features.
Patterning strategy and performance of 1.3NA tool for 32nm node lithography
Show abstract
We have designed the lithography process for 32nm node logic devices under the 1.3NA single exposure
conditions. The simulation and experimental results indicate that the minimum pitches should be
determined as 100nm for line pattern and 120nm for contact hole pattern, respectively. The isolated
feature needs SRAF to pull up the DOF margin. High density SRAM cell with 0.15um2 area is clearly
resolved across exposure and focus window. The 1.3NA scanner has sufficient focus and overlay stability.
There is no immersion induced defects.
Double Masking III
Post-decomposition assessment of double patterning layout
Show abstract
Pattern matching methods are examined as fast-CAD tools for full-chip across process window examination of postdecomposition
double patterning layouts. The goal is to demonstrate the ability to anticipate lithographic weakness due
to many sources. This includes the decomposition strategy itself, OPC of individual sub-layers, focus-exposure process
window and illumination. This study is an intermediate step to using fast-CAD assessment tools within pattern
decomposition algorithms to guide decisions based on lateral influences instead of rules. The accuracy of the pattern
matcher as a method for hot spot detection is investigated, and a model relating coma match factors and edge movement
is refined to have an R2 value of 0.95. The validity of the pattern matcher is explored by relating pre-OPC matches to
post-OPC matches, and by showing that the lateral influence functions for Z0 and Z3 have high matches at distinct
locations, implying that OPC which corrects for one of Z0 and Z3 will not necessarily correct for the other. The pattern
matcher is run on a post decomposition layout and locations are identified with high variability under coma, and their
sensitivity is verified with aerial image simulations. For one such example, a different split is made and the match factor
drops by 55%.
Alternative process schemes for double patterning that eliminate the intermediate etch step
Show abstract
Double patterning is used to scale designs below k1 factors that can be obtained with single patterning. Because of the
double litho and etch steps, however, this is an expensive and time consuming technique. Spacer defined double
patterning, which is commonly used to shrink regular dense patterns as used in memory applications, is an expensive
technique because of the many deposition and etch steps that are required. In this paper, we propose several alternative
process flows which can reduce the cost-of-ownership by eliminating the intermediate etch step in a double litho, double
etch for line/space patterns, and replace it by a process step in the track only. These alternative process flows use thermal
freezing resist, positive/negative resist and coating a freezing material. For these materials 32nm node logic patterning
can be demonstrated, and even 32nm half pitch can be patterned already with one technique. As alternative technique to
spacer defined double patterning, dual tone development is proposed, which can generate pitch doubling in resist using a
single exposure. Proof-of-concept of this technique is shown experimentally.
Double patterning down to k1=0.15 with bilayer resist
Show abstract
Double patterning based on litho-etch-litho-etch techniques requires the fabrication of small lines or of small spaces after
first patterning. If spacer techniques are used for pitch fragmentation small lines are needed as carrier in dense arrays. In
any case the CD control is crucial. Focus of this paper is the patterning of small lines with bilayer resist in comparison
with single layer resist as pre-requisite for both methods, for various litho conditions. The basic suitability of a bilayer
patterning has been demonstrated at k1=0.146 at half pitch of 37.5nm with a sufficient process window and a good CD
uniformity after litho and after etch. Single layer resists suffer from pattern collapse and resist thickness loss at defocus if
a CD trim by litho "overexposure" is applied. This results in deficiency of masking during etch, although the resist
profiles and litho process windows look perfect. If a CD trim is achieved by an etch process the CDU is diminished and
the minimum patterned space is enlarged compared to bilayer, due the widening by trim etch. The bilayer resist for
193nm dry lithography showed convincing overall performance. First results with 193nm immersion bilayer look also
promising but shows grass formation.
Double patterning requirements for optical lithography and prospects for optical extension without double patterning
Show abstract
Double patterning (DP) has now become a fixture on the development roadmaps of many device manufacturers for half
pitches of 32 nm and beyond. Depending on the device feature, different types of DP and double exposure (DE) are
being considered. This paper focuses on the requirements of the most complex forms of DP, pitch splitting, where line
density is doubled through two exposures, and sidewall processes, where a deposition process is used to achieve the final
pattern. Budgets for CD uniformity and overlay are presented along with tool and process requirements to achieve these
budgets. Experimental results showing 45 nm lines and spaces using dry ArF lithography with a k1 factor of 0.20 are
presented to highlight some of the challenges. Finally, alternatives to double patterning are presented.
Simulation I
Making a trillion pixels dance
Show abstract
In June 2007, Intel announced a new pixelated mask technology. This technology was created to address the problem
caused by the growing gap between the lithography wavelength and the feature sizes patterned with it. As this gap has
increased, the quality of the image has deteriorated. About a decade ago, Optical Proximity Correction (OPC) was
introduced to bridge this gap, but as this gap continued to increase, one could not rely on the same basic set of
techniques to maintain image quality. The computational lithography group at Intel sought to alleviate this problem by
experimenting with additional degrees of freedom within the mask. This paper describes the resulting pixelated mask
technology, and some of the computational methods used to create it. The first key element of this technology is a thick
mask model. We realized very early in the development that, unlike traditional OPC methods, the pixelated mask would
require a very accurate thick mask model. Whereas in the traditional methods, one can use the relatively coarse
approximations such as the boundary layer method, use of such techniques resulted not just in incorrect sizing of parts of
the pattern, but in whole features missing. We built on top of previously published domain decomposition methods, and
incorporated limitations of the mask manufacturing process, to create an accurate thick mask model. Several additional
computational techniques were invoked to substantially increase the speed of this method to a point that it was feasible
for full chip tapeout. A second key element of the computational scheme was the comprehension of mask
manufacturability, including the vital issue of the number of colors in the mask. While it is obvious that use of three or
more colors will give the best image, one has to be practical about projecting mask manufacturing capabilities for such a
complex mask. To circumvent this serious issue, we eventually settled on a two color mask - comprising plain glass and
etched glass. In addition, there were several smaller manufacturability concerns, for example a "1X1" glass pillar (an
isolated 0 phase pixel) were susceptible to collapse under the stress of mask processing, and therefore these had to be
constrained out of the final configuration. A third key element was defining the objective function. We experimented
with a large number of choices and eventually settled on a form that allows us to trade-off fidelity and contrast. A fourth
key element was the optimization algorithm. The number of possible configurations for a trillion pixels present on our
final product mask is greater than the number of total elementary particles in the known universe, so finding the
proverbial needle in this haystack was difficult to say the least. We chose a mixture of stochastic and direct descent
algorithms to find an arrangement that meets the demands. While we have not proved we are close to the absolute global
minimum, we conducted several experiments to suggest this is the case. A fifth key element, and a large one at that, was
scaling up our software system from micron length scale to centimeter length scale required for full chip tapeout. This
software, in turn, has several key components - hierarchy handling, the non-trivial handling of pixelated domain
boundaries, repair of regions not converged in terms of image quality, and verification of the entire assembled database.
All elements described above were validated through the tapeout of an actual mask to pattern the most complex metal
layer for the leading 65nm node microprocessor in high volume manufacturing. This very first experimental tapeout
resulted in wafer parts yield comparable to yields on mass produced wafers made with production 65nm technology.
Validation of inverse lithography technology (ILT) and its adaptive SRAF at advanced technology nodes
Show abstract
In this paper, an overview of Inverse Lithography Technology (ILT) based on Level Set Methods (LSM) is provided.
Applications of ILT in the advanced lithography process are then shown for several different devices, including DRAM,
SRAM, FLASH, random logic, and imaging devices. ILT is used to correct the main patterns, as well as automatically
insert SRAFs using model-based mathematical methods. The process of SRAF generation in ILT is unified with the
process of inversion. With the help of ILT, SRAFs can be inserted where physically needed, independent of source
parameters or target patterns. Results that demonstrate the adaptive nature of ILT SRAF insertion capability are
presented. Wafer verification results were collected by multiple advanced semiconductor manufacturing companies at
advanced technology nodes, including 45nm and 32nm nodes, and compared with their current OPC solution. Final
wafer results presented here demonstrate that ILT improves pattern fidelity, enlarges process window, and provides
remarkable control for line-end shortening.
General imaging of advanced 3D mask objects based on the fully-vectorial extended Nijboer-Zernike (ENZ) theory
Show abstract
In this paper we introduce a new mask imaging algorithm that is based on the source point integration method
(or Abbe method). The method presented here distinguishes itself from existing methods by exploiting the
through-focus imaging feature of the Extended Nijboer-Zernike (ENZ) theory of diffraction. An introduction
to ENZ-theory and its application in general imaging is provided after which we describe the mask imaging
scheme that can be derived from it. The remainder of the paper is devoted to illustrating the advantages of the
new method over existing methods (Hopkins-based). To this extent several simulation results are included that
illustrate advantages arising from: the accurate incorporation of isolated structures, the rigorous treatment of the
object (mask topography) and the fully vectorial through-focus image formation of the ENZ-based algorithm.
Radiometric consistency in source specifications for lithography
Show abstract
There is a surprising lack of clarity about the exact quantity that a lithographic source map should specify. Under the
plausible interpretation that input source maps should tabulate radiance, one will find with standard imaging codes that
simulated wafer plane source intensities appear to violate the brightness theorem. The apparent deviation (a cosine
factor in the illumination pupil) represents one of many obliquity/inclination factors involved in propagation through the
imaging system whose interpretation in the literature is often somewhat obscure, but which have become numerically
significant in today's hyper-NA OPC applications. We show that the seeming brightness distortion in the illumination
pupil arises because the customary direction-cosine gridding of this aperture yields non-uniform solid-angle subtense in
the source pixels. Once the appropriate solid angle factor is included, each entry in the source map becomes
proportional to the total |E|^2 that the associated pixel produces on the mask. This quantitative definition of lithographic
source distributions is consistent with the plane-wave spectrum approach adopted by litho simulators, in that these
simulators essentially propagate |E|^2 along the interfering diffraction orders from the mask input to the resist film. It
can be shown using either the rigorous Franz formulation of vector diffraction theory, or an angular spectrum approach,
that such an |E|^2 plane-wave weighting will provide the standard inclination factor if the source elements are incoherent
and the mask model is accurate. This inclination factor is usually derived from a classical Rayleigh-Sommerfeld
diffraction integral, and we show that the nominally discrepant inclination factors used by the various diffraction
integrals of this class can all be made to yield the same result as the Franz formula when rigorous mask simulation is
employed, and further that these cosine factors have a simple geometrical interpretation. On this basis one can then
obtain for the lens as a whole the standard mask-to-wafer obliquity factor used by litho simulators. This obliquity factor
is shown to express the brightness invariance theorem, making the simulator's output consistent with the brightness
theorem if the source map tabulates the product of radiance and pixel solid angle, as our source definition specifies. We
show by experiment that dose-to-clear data can be modeled more accurately when the correct obliquity factor is used.
Coupled-dipole modelling for 3D mask simulation
Show abstract
The growing importance of mask simulation in a low-k1 realm is matched by an increasing need for numerical methods
capable of handling complex 3D configurations. Various approximations applied to physical parameters or boundary
conditions allowed a few methods to achieve reasonable run-times. In this work the theoretical foundation and
simulation results of an alternative 3D mask modeling method suitable for OPC simulations are presented. We have
established the throughput and accuracy of the Coupled-Dipole Simulation Method and have compared results to the
rigorous FDTD approach using a test pattern. We will discuss in detail possible approximations needed in order to
accelerate the method's performance.
Simulation II
Generalized inverse problem for partially coherent projection lithography
Show abstract
In this paper, we will outline general mathematical techniques applied to the solution of the inverse problem for
partially coherent lithographic imaging. The forward imaging problem is reviewed and its solution is discussed
within the framework of 2D sampling and matrix coherence theory. The intensity distribution on the wafer is
shown to be a bilinear functional in the sampled mask transmission values, and represents a continuous sparse set
of variables for optimization. We review various iterative techniques to optimize the sampled mask transmission,
called a tau-map. From the optimal tau-map, a procedure is required to construct a pixelated mask representation
with restricted transmission values. This mask representation is not unique since the problem is ill-posed, and
leads to multiple mask solutions for a single optimal tau-map. Various procedures based on spectral techniques
and principle component analysis to quantize the mask are reviewed.
Massively-parallel FDTD simulations to address mask electromagnetic effects in hyper–NA immersion lithography
Show abstract
In the Hyper-NA immersion lithography regime, the electromagnetic response of the reticle is known to deviate
in a complicated manner from the idealized Thin-Mask-like behavior. Already, this is driving certain RET
choices, such as the use of polarized illumination and the customization of reticle film stacks. Unfortunately,
full 3-D electromagnetic mask simulations are computationally intensive. And while OPC-compatible mask
electromagnetic field (EMF) models can offer a reasonable tradeoff between speed and accuracy for full-chip
OPC applications, full understanding of these complex physical effects demands higher accuracy.
Our paper describes recent advances in leveraging High Performance Computing as a critical step towards
lithographic modeling of the full manufacturing process. In this paper, highly accurate full 3-D electromagnetic
simulation of very large mask layouts are conducted in parallel with reasonable turnaround time, using a Blue-
Gene/L supercomputer and a Finite-Difference Time-Domain (FDTD) code developed internally within IBM. A
3-D simulation of a large 2-D layout spanning 5μm×5μm at the wafer plane (and thus (20μm×20μm×0.5μm at
the mask) results in a simulation with roughly 12.5GB of memory (grid size of 10nm at the mask, single-precision
computation, about 30 bytes/grid point). FDTD is flexible and easily parallelizable to enable full simulations
of such large layout in approximately an hour using one BlueGene/L "midplane" containing 512 dual-processor
nodes with 256MB of memory per processor. Our scaling studies on BlueGene/L demonstrate that simulations
up to 100μm × 100μm at the mask can be computed in a few hours. Finally, we will show that the use of a
subcell technique permits accurate simulation of features smaller than the grid discretization, thus improving on
the tradeoff between computational complexity and simulation accuracy.
We demonstrate the correlation of the real and quadrature components that comprise the Boundary Layer
representation of the EMF behavior of a mask blank to intensity measurements of the mask diffraction patterns
by an Aerial Image Measurement System (AIMS) with polarized illumination. We also discuss how this model
can become a powerful tool for the assessment of the impact to the lithographic process of a mask blank.
Polarization characteristics of state-of-art lithography optics reconstructed from on-body measurement
Show abstract
In hyper-NA imaging, the vector properties of the light become important. Therefore, to characterize and to fully exploit
the state-of-the-art lithographic apparatus, reconstruction of polarization matrices in the pupil plain of a projection lens
has become indispensable. We will present a reconstructed Jones matrix of a benchtest projection optic. The
reconstruction method is based on the concept of the first canonical coordinate of the Lie group, which conjures up a
geometrical approach. The Jones matrix of this benchtest immersion projection lens is successfully reconstructed using
the data obtained by an on-body tool called iPot. A reconstructed polarized wavefront and polarized wavefront measured
by iPot agree very well. This newly developed methodology is essential to capturing the nature of light transformations
in the hyper-NA projection lenses. It is of fundamental importance to quantifying the properties of the state-of-the-art
projection lenses used in lithography.
Extended Nijboer-Zernike (ENZ) based mask imaging: efficient coupling of electromagnetic field solvers and the ENZ imaging algorithm
Show abstract
Results are presented of mask imaging using the Extended Nijboer-Zernike (ENZ) theory of diffraction. We
show that the efficiency of a mask imaging algorithm, derived from this theory, can be increased. By adjusting
the basic Finite Difference Time Domain (FDTD) algorithm, we can calculate the near field of isolated mask
structures efficiently, without resorting to periodic domains. In addition, the calculations for the points on the
entrance sphere of the imaging system can be done separately with a Fourier transformed Stratton-Chu nearto-
far-field transformation. By clever sampling in the radial direction of the entrance pupil, the computational
effort is already reduced by at least a factor of 4.
Evaluating the accuracy of a calibrated rigorous physical resist model under various process and illumination conditions
Show abstract
If RET selection by simulation is to be successful for the deep sub-wavelength technologies
of today, then the predictions of the simulator must be quantitatively accurate over the parameter
space of interest. The Rigorous Physical resist Model (RPM) within PROLITH and Lithoware is
separable from the illumination conditions and the reflection behavior of the wafer stack, and thus
should be an excellent candidate for such projects.
In this work, the RPM is calibrated for a commercially available ArF photoresist using topdown
CD-SEM data, including focus-exposure matrices and CD vs. mask pitch data, under fixed
process conditions. It will be shown that this RPM is able to predict the performance of line, trench
and contact features, with quantitative accuracy, under different numerical aperture and illumination
conditions, even when the wafer stack is altered significantly. The stack alterations include resist
thickness change, the presence or absence of an immersion topcoat, substitution of different
underlying substrate materials and the use of a single or double layer anti-reflection coating. The
resist model accurately describes both the experimental calibration data and two separate
experimental validation datasets. The RMS error seen in the extrapolative predictions is comparable
to that observed between the model and the original calibration dataset.
High Index Immersion Lithography
High refractive index materials design for the next generation ArF immersion lithography
Show abstract
High-refractive-index fluids (HIFs) are being considered to replace water as the immersion fluid in
next generation 193nm immersion scanner. We have demonstrated the attractive optical properties for our HIF
candidates, HIL-001, HIL-203 and HIL-204. Especially, HIL-203 and HIL-204 have higher transmittance
compared to water. In this paper, we describe our latest results on the comparative evaluations including
photo-degradation behavior and lens contamination phenomenon in a flow system. For laser induced fluid
degradation behavior, it was shown the higher initial transmittance resulted in the higher laser durability.
However, the complicated phenomenon was observed for the lens contamination test. That is, HIL-204 with
higher initial transmittance showed higher lens contamination rate than HIL-203. From several analyses, the
complicated behaviors among HILs were speculated to be caused by the different nature of photo-degraded
impurities. In order to control the fluid transmittance change and suppress the lens contamination during
exposure, the refining process was definitely necessary for HIL reuse system. Based on the refining mechanism
and the refining material design, we have developed an appropriate refinement unit named Refine B. This
approach provided us with the result that Refine B could control the change of fluid transmittance and suppress
the lens contamination rate.
Studies of high index immersion lithography
Show abstract
High index immersion lithography is one of the candidates for next generation lithography technology following water
immersion lithography. This technology may be most attractive for the industry since it is effective in raising resolution
without seriously changing the chip making processes. This motivates us to continue to study further NA expansion
although there are many challenges with respect to either high index fluid development or high index lens material
development. In this paper, the current status of high index lithography development compared with the industry's
requirements is discussed while considering design feasibility.
High-n immersion lithography
Show abstract
A two-year study on the feasibility of High-n Immersion Lithography shows very promising results. This
paper reports the findings of the study.
The evaluation shows the tremendous progress made in the development of second-generation
immersion fluid technology. Candidate fluids from several suppliers have been evaluated. All the
commercial fluids evaluated are viable, so there are a number of options. Life tests have been conducted on
bench top fluid-handling systems and the results referenced to full-scale systems. Parameters such as Dose
per Laser Pulse, Pulse Rate, Fluid Flow Rate, and Fluid Absorbency at 193nm, and Oxygen/Air
Contamination Levels were explored. A detailed evaluation of phenomena such as Last Lens Element
(LLE) contamination has been conducted. Lens cleaning has been evaluated.
A comparison of High-n fluid-based technology and water-based immersion technology shows
interesting advantages of High-n fluid in the areas of Defect and Resist Interaction. Droplet Drying tests,
Resist Staining evaluations, and Resist Contrast impact studies have all been run. Defect-generating
mechanisms have been identified and are being eliminated. The lower evaporation rate of the High-n fluids
compared with water shows the advantages of High-n Immersion.
The core issue for the technology, the availability of High-n optical material for use as the final
lens element, is updated. Samples of LuAG material have been received from development partners and
have been evaluated. The latest status of optical materials and the technology timelines are reported.
The potential impact of the availability of the technology is discussed. Synergy with technologies
such as Double Patterning is discussed. The prospects for <22nm (hp) are evaluated.
High-index immersion lithography: preventing lens photocontamination and identifying optical behavior of LuAG
Show abstract
A potential extension of water-based 193-nm immersion lithography involves transition to a higher refractive index
organic immersion fluid coupled with a higher index last lens element. While considerable progress has been made in
improving the photo-durability of the immersion fluid itself, photo-induced contamination of the last lens element
caused by laser exposure in the presence of such organic fluids remains a major concern. In this work, we study
remediation strategies for such contamination, which would be compatible with conventional lithographic production
environments. In general, surface photocontamination layers were found to be highly graphitic in nature, where the
first monolayer is strongly bound to the substrate. We have attempted to develop a surface passivation treatment for
altering the monolayer chemistry and preventing large-scale contamination, but found such treatments to be unstable
under laser irradiation. On the other hand, using hydrogen peroxide as a in-situ cleaning solution has been shown to be
extremely effective. We also present first laser-based durability results of LuAG, which is a leading candidate
material for high index last element to be used with high index fluids.
High-index immersion fluids enabling cost-effective single-exposure lithography for 32 nm half pitches
Show abstract
We have performed high-index immersion fluid studies to define the levels of both soluble and insoluble impurities
present. These studies have also revealed the importance of process materials' purity in fluid contact. Fluid interactions
with resist, leading to both surface and imaging defects, can be minimized by proper resist selection. Our Active Recycle
Package technology can greatly extend the useful life of both the fluid itself, as well as the final lens element.
Process I
Immersion defectivity study with volume production immersion lithography tool for 45 nm node and below
Show abstract
Volume production of 45nm node devices utilizing Nikon's S610C immersion lithography tool has started. Important to
the success in achieving high-yields in volume production with immersion lithography has been defectivity reduction. In
this study we evaluate several methods of defectivity reduction. The tools used in our defectivity analysis included a
dedicated immersion cluster tools consisting of a Nikon S610C, a volume production immersion exposure tool with NA
of 1.3, and a resist coater-developer LITHIUS i+ from TEL. In our initial procedure we evaluated defectivity behavior
by comparing on a topcoat-less resist process to a conventional topcoat process. Because of its simplicity the topcoatless
resist shows lower defect levels than the topcoat process. In a second study we evaluated the defect reduction by
introducing the TEL bevel rinse and pre-immersion bevel cleaning techniques. This technique was shown to
successfully reduce the defect levels by reducing the particles at the wafer bevel region. For the third defect reduction
method, two types of tool cleaning processes are shown. Finally, we discuss the overall defectivity behavior at the 45nm
node. To facilitate an understanding of the root cause of the defects, defect source analysis (DSA) was applied to
separate the defects into three classes according to the source of defects. DSA analysis revealed that more than 99% of
defects relate to material and process, and less than 1% of the defects relate to the exposure tool. Material and process
optimization by collaborative work between exposure tool vendors, track vendors and material vendors is a key for
success of 45nm node device manufacturing.
Focus, dynamics, and defectivity performance at wafer edge in immersion lithography
Show abstract
We evaluate several types of wafers and investigate the effect of wafer edge geometry on focus, dynamics and
defectivity performance in ArF immersion lithography. Wafer edge geometry includes both edge shape (e.g. short, long,
full round etc.) and edge roll-off (ERO) here. We found that focus accuracy at wafer edge depends on ERO, especially
on ZDD (Z double derivative) and if we use the specified wafer which has low ZDD value, it keeps same good focus
accuracy at the edge area as the one at the wafer center area. Dynamics (stage synchronization accuracy) was
independent of wafer diameter, thickness and edge geometry. We also found that defectivity was strongly dependent on
the edge shape. More bridging defects were found on the short edge wafer than the long edge wafer. This is related with
wafer edge conditions after coating and during exposure.
The rapid introduction of immersion lithography for NAND flash: challenges and experience
Show abstract
Immersion technology is definitely the mainstream lithography technology for NAND FLASH in recent years since
hyper-NA immersion technology drives the resolution limit down to the 40-50 nm half pitch region. Immersion
defectivity and overlay issues are key challenges before introducing immersion technology into mass production. In this
work, both long term immersion defectivity and overlay data, as well as good photoresist performance, show the Nikon
S610C immersion scanner plus LITHIUS i+ cluster is capable of 40-50 nm NAND FLASH mass production. Immersion
defects are classified based on their causes, and no tool specific immersion defects, e.g. bubbles and water marks, were
found in the Nikon S610C plus TEL LITHIUS i+ cluster. Materials-induced immersion defects require more attention to
achieve production-worthy results.
Immersion defect performance and particle control method for 45nm mass production
Show abstract
Water-based immersion technology has overcome various challenges and is starting to be used for the 45nm-node mass
production. However, even though immersion technology is being used in memory device production, significant
improvement in defect performance is needed before the technology can be used for logic devices. Canon has developed
an immersion exposure system, the FPA-7000AS7, with numerical aperture of 1.35. In the AS7 immersion tool, there is
little influence of vibration and evaporative cooling. The AS7 has an in-situ cleaning system in order to remove particles
carried into the exposure tool. We evaluated the contamination of the projection lens and immersion nozzle due to photoacid
generator (PAG) leaching from resist to water. We evaluated the cleaning effects of various cleaning processes and
found the suitable processes for cleaning the projection lens and immersion nozzle from the view that it does not
adversely affect the exposure tool: damage-free and easy drainage treatment. In addition, we evaluated the influence of
particles on the wafer stage, since there is a major concern that particles entering the water may increase the defects. The
number of particles adhering on the wafer during an exposure sequence can be reduced with the wafer stage cleaning.
Periodical cleaning keeps the wafer stage clean, thus preventing the increase of exposure defects caused by particles. We
performed a defect evaluation with the AS7. The average defect density was 0.042/cm2 in the continuous exposure
process of 25 wafers with a developer-soluble topcoat. Circle defects and bubble defects were not observed.
OPC and Mask Technology
Development of a computational lithography roadmap
Show abstract
While lithography R&D community at large has already gotten the mind set for 32nm, all eyes are on 22nm node.
Current consensus is to employ computational lithography to meet wafer CD uniformity (CDU) requirement. Resolution
enhancement technologies (RET) and model OPC are the two fundamental components for computational lithography.
Today's full-chip CDU specifications are already pushing physical limits at extreme lithography k1 factor. While
increasingly aggressive RET either by double exposure or double patterning are enabling imaging performance, for CDU
control we need ever more accurate OPC at a greater computational efficiency.
In this report, we discuss the desire for wanting more robust and accurate OPC models. One important trend is to have
predictive OPC models allowing accurate OPC results to be obtained much faster, shortening the qualification process
for exposure tools. We investigate several key parameters constitute to accuracy achievable in computational
lithography. Such as the choice of image pixel size, numbers of terms needed for transmission cross coefficients (TCC),
and "safe" ambit radius for assuring accurate CD prediction. Selections of image pixel size and "safe" ambit radius
together determine % utilization for 2D fast Fourier transformation (FFT) for efficient full-chip OPC computation. For
IC manufacturing beyond ArF, we made initial observations and estimations on EUV computational lithography. These
discussions pave the way for developing a computational lithography roadmap extends to the end of Moore's Law. This
computational lithography roadmap aims to be a complement for the current ITRS roadmap on what does it take to
achieve CD correction accuracy.
Analysis of OPC optical model accuracy with detailed scanner information
Show abstract
Production optical proximity correction (OPC) tools employ compact optical models in order to accurately
predict complicated optical lithography systems with good theoretical accuracy. Theoretical accuracy is
not the same as usable prediction accuracy in a real lithographic imaging system. Real lithographic
systems have deviations from ideal behavior in the process, illumination, projection and mechanical
systems as well as in metrology. The deviations from the ideal are small but non-negligible. For this study
we use realistic process variations and scanner values to perform a detailed study of useful OPC model
accuracy vs. the variation from ideal behavior and vs. theoretical OPC accuracy. The study is performed
for different 32nm lithographic processes. The results clearly show that incorporating realistic process,
metrology and imaging tool signatures is significantly more important to predictive accuracy than small
improvements in theoretical accuracy.
Hybrid Hopkins-Abbe method for modeling oblique angle mask effects in OPC
Show abstract
A new method for the simulation of diffraction limited images is presented that is suitable for application in optical
proximity correction and verification, where fast execution is critical. The method is given the name hybrid Hopkins-Abbe,
because it is literally a hybrid of Hopkins' and Abbe's diffraction theories. The hybrid Hopkin--Abbe method resolves the
problem of the traditional Hopkins theory, namely the requirement for constant mask diffraction efficiencies. Simulation
of electromagnetic scattering from the mask that takes into account the oblique angles of incidence from the illumination
is performed by application of the domain decomposition method that is extended for offaxis illumination. Examples of
45nm and 32nm lines and spaces through pitch and through focus are presented to demonstrate the validity and accuracy
of the hybrid Hopkins-Abbe method. The results obtained are in excellent agreement with a rigorous and independent (third
party) simulator. Other aspects of hybrid Hopkins-Abbe method relevant to OPC application are also discussed.
Robust PPC and DFM methodology for exposure tool variations
Show abstract
Robust optical proximity correction (OPC) and design for manufacturability (DFM) methodology for optical
variation among exposure tools is proposed. It is demonstrated that application of the methodology improves standard
deviation of CD difference for target CD by 33% compared with the case of using the conventional methodology. Under
the low-k1 lithography condition, hot spots induced by optical variation among exposure tools delay ramp-up of
production of high-volume products. To realize robust pattern formation for all exposure tools, the following new
methodologies are introduced : i) OPC modeling methodology using actual optics of primary tool, ii) OPC processing
methodology using averaged or designed optics, iii) at the design stage, hot spot detection within the optical variation
space centered on average or designed optics and hot spot fixing by layout modification or OPC optimization, iv) at the
manufacturing stage, hot spot detection using actual optics and hot spot fixing by optical adjustment of troubled tool.
Fabrication of defect-free full-field pixelated phase mask
Show abstract
Pixelated phase masks rendered from computational lithography techniques demand one generation-ahead mask
technology development. In this paper, we reveal the accomplishment of fabricating Cr-less, full field, defect-free
pixilated phase masks, including integration of tapeout, front-end patterning and backend defect inspection, repair,
disposition and clean. This work was part of a comprehensive program within Intel which demonstrated microprocessor
device yield.
To pattern mask pixels with lateral sizes <100nm and vertical depth of 170nm, tapeout data management, ebeam write
time management, aggressive pattern resolution scaling, etch improvement, new tool insertion and process integration
were co-optimized to ensure good linearity of lateral, vertical dimensions and sidewall angle of glass pixels of arbitrary
pixelated layout, including singlets, doublets, triplets, touch-corners and larger scale features of structural tones
including pit/trench and pillar/mesa. The final residual systematic mask patterning imperfections were corrected and
integrated upstream in the optical model and design layout.
The volume of 100nm phase pixels on a full field reticle is on the order tera-scale magnitude. Multiple breakthroughs in
backend mask technology were required to achieve a defect free full field mask. Specifically, integration of aerial
image-based defect inspection, 3D optical model-based high resolution ebeam repair and disposition were introduced.
Significant reduction of pixel mask specific defect modes, such as electro static discharge and glass pattern collapse,
were executed to drive defect level down to single digit before attempt of repair. The defect printability and repair yield
were verified downstream through silicon wafer print test to validate defect free mask performance.
Advanced OPC and 2D verification for tip engineering using aggressive illuminations
Show abstract
In this paper advanced OPC (Optical Proximity Correction) methods, additional with assistant features, and non-obvious
methods were implemented to correct aberrations caused by aggressive illuminations in order to optimize the shape of
the finger tips. OPC model and simulations were verified using 2D verification method.
Process II
Optimization procedure of exposure tools with polarization aberrations
Show abstract
In the Hyper-NA immersion age, it is essential to optimize all optical parameters, and so exposure tools must have
functions to precisely control the parameters.
There have been various reports indicating that polarization aberrations of projection optics affect imaging performance,
but there have been few reports on reducing their influence in tools. We have developed a new method to optimize
imaging performance with polarization taken into account.
This paper describes a theoretical analysis of polarization with Pauli decomposition. A strict vectorial calculation of
optical images matches our expression. Then, our solver software can determine the optimum conditions of all
aberration parameters of exposure tools for specific IC patterns.
Proposal for determining exposure latitude requirements
Show abstract
To determine the magnitude of the exposure latitude required for a process to be manufacturable, additional factors are
considered that have a similar relationship between linewidth variation and image log-slope. Such parameters include
resist thickness, flare, post-exposure bake temperature, and line-edge roughness. To obtain consistency between theory
and experiment it is necessary to use the resist-edge log-slope generalization of image log-slope. Inclusion of these
additional factors increases the required exposure latitude five to six times more than would be considered necessary
from exposure tool dose control alone.
Influence of shot noise on CDU with DUV, EUV, and E-beam
Show abstract
A theoretical analysis to estimate the effect of shot noise on CDU is induced from optical imaging perspectives combined
with quantum theory, and is studied for 193-nm, EUV, and electron beam lithography. We found the CDU variation
from shot noise is related to the number of particles absorbed in the printed area and to the image log slope (ILS). Hence,
the CDU variation contributed by shot noise gets worse when the technology node advances from 45- to 32-, 22-, and
15-nm, EUV with higher ILS is no exception. For e-beam lithography, we are interested in the values of ILS calculated
from array structures with different pitches, backscattering, wafer-stage movement, and raster-scan writing.
Determining DOF requirements needed to meet technology process assumptions
Show abstract
Depth of Focus (DOF) and exposure latitude requirements have long been ambiguous. Techniques range from scaling
values from previous generations to summing individual components from the scanner. Even more ambiguous is what
critical dimension (CD) variation can be allowed to originate from dose and focus variation. In this paper we discuss a
comprehensive approach to measuring focus variation that a process must be capable of handling. We also describe a
detailed methodology to determine how much CD variation can come from dose and focus variation. This includes
examples of the statistics used to combine individual components of CD, dose and focus variation.
Extending scatterometry to the measurements of sub 40 nm features, double patterning structures, and 3D OPC patterns
Show abstract
This paper examines the extendibility of the scatterometry techniques to characterize structures pushing the limits of
current lithographic printing technologies. In particular, we investigate the limits of normal-incidence optical CD (NIOCD)
measurements using the smallest features afforded by the most recent generation of hyper-NA immersion
scanners. Special analysis techniques have also been developed and applied to cases relevant to double exposure and
double patterning lithography. Models were used successfully to decouple CD and overlay values associated with
patterning the first and second set of features on the wafer, using a single scatterometry measurement. These advances
pave the way to the development of full solutions for the general case of double patterning structures with two different
populations of lines or structures.
In addition, the current study focused on seeking a better understanding of the use of scatterometry 3D features
characterization, particularly as it relates to OPC model building and verification. The demonstration of tip-to-tip
measurements on 3D structures is very encouraging as it introduces the advantages of scatterometry, such as reduced
influence of line-edge roughness (LER) and better precision, to the practice of advanced OPC model building.
Lithography Tools I
Recent performance results of Nikon immersion lithography tools
Show abstract
Nikon's production immersion scanners, including the NSR-S609B and the NSR-S610C, have now been in the field for
over 2 years. With these tools, 55 nm NAND Flash processes became the first immersion production chips in the world,
and 45 nm NAND Flash process development and early production has begun. Several logic processes have also been
developed on these tools. This paper discusses the technical features of Nikon's immersion tools, and their results in
production.
Performance of the FPA-7000AS7 1.35 NA immersion exposure system for 45-nm mass production
Show abstract
Canon has developed an immersion exposure tool, the FPA-7000AS7 (AS7), with the industry's highest NA of 1.35.
This paper reports on its performance. The AS7's projection lens achieves ultra-low aberration with total RMS of less
than 5 mλ and flare of less than 0.5%. The resolution capability is 37 nm with k1 = 0.259, and DOF of 0.8 μm was
obtained owing to the ultra-low aberration and low flare. Regarding focus performance, a 3σ value of 19.3 nm for Lstage
and 16.1nm for R-stage were attained in a whole area. The result of CD uniformity of 1.91nm (3σ) was obtained
across the wafer with a total of 4032 measurement points. Distortion was 3.9 nm at the worst value. On the other hand
the most critical issue of immersion is defects, so the nozzle, lens and stage must be cleaned to reduce defects. The result
of defect evaluation of the AS7 was an average of 0.042 defect/cm2 from 25 wafers in a lot and average 0.046 defect
count/cm2 from long-term defect evaluation for two months. From these results, we are confident that the AS7 is capable
of 45-nm node device production.
Latest developments on immersion exposure systems
Show abstract
Immersion lithography has been developed in a tremendous pace. Starting in late 2001, the technology now has moved
to volume production of advanced flash memories. The immersion exposure system has been the key enabler in this
progress. In this paper we discuss the evolution of the TWINSCAN immersion scanning exposure tools, and present an
overview of its performance on imaging, lens heating control, overlay, focus and defects. It is shown that stable
performance assures 45-nm device volume manufacturing. Extendibility of immersion towards 38-nm and 32-nm is
discussed. For NAND the next device half pitch will be around 38-nm and it is shown that with 1.35 NA and low k1
dipole or CQUAD illumination a final extension with single exposure is possible. For the 32-nm node and beyond
double patterning methods are required till EUV lithography is ready to be used in volume production. To secure tight
CD tolerance the overlay performance of the immersion tools need to be tightened to numbers well below 3-nm. The
paper presents overlay improvements towards the requirements for double patterning.
Tool-to-tool optical proximity effect matching
Show abstract
IC manufacturers have a strong demand for transferring a working process from one scanner to another. In an ideal
transfer, a reticle set that produces devices within specification on a certain scanner has the same performance on another
exposure tool. In real life, however, reticles employ optical proximity correction (OPC) which incorporates by definition
the inherent optical fingerprint of a specific exposure tool and process. In order to avoid the additional cost of developing
a new OPC model and acquiring a new reticle for each exposure tool, IC manufacturers therefore wish to "match" the
optical fingerprint of their scanners as closely as possible.
In this paper, we report on the matching strategy that we developed to perform a tool-to-tool matching. We present
experimental matching results for several tool combinations at numerical apertures (NA) 0.75, 0.85 and 1.2. Matching of
two exposure tools is obtained by determining the sensitivities to scanner parameter variations like NA, Sigma, Focus
Drilling, Ellipticity and Dose from wafer data and/or simulations. These sensitivities are used to calculate the optimal
scanner parameters for matching the two tools.
XLR 600i: recirculating ring ArF light source for double patterning immersion lithography
Show abstract
Double patterning (DP) lithography is expected to be deployed at the 32nm node to enable the extension of high NA
(≥1.3) scanner systems currently used for 45nm technology. Increasing the light source power is one approach to address
the intrinsically lower throughput that DP imposes. Improved energy stability also provides a means to improve
throughput by enabling fewer pulses per exposure slit window, which in turn enables the use of higher scanner stage
speeds. Current excimer laser light sources for deep UV immersion lithography are operating with powers as high as
60W at 6 kHz repetition rates. In this paper, we describe the introduction of the XLR 600i, a 6 kHz excimer laser that
produces 90W power, based on a recirculating ring technology. Improved energy stability is inherent to the ring
technology. Key to the successful acceptance of such a higher power, or higher energy laser is the ability to reduce
operating costs. For this reason, the recirculating ring technology provides some unique advantages that cannot be
realized with conventional excimer lasers today. Longer intrinsic pulse durations that develop in the multi-pass ring
architecture reduce the peak power that the optics are subjected to, thereby improving lifetime. The ring architecture also
improves beam uniformity that results in a significantly reduced peak energy density, another key factor in preserving
optics lifetime within the laser as well as in the scanner. Furthermore, in a drive to reduce operating costs while
providing advanced technical capability, the XLR 600i includes an advanced gas control management system that
extends the time between gas refills by a factor of ten, offering a significant improvement in productive time. Finally, the
XLR 600i provides a novel bandwidth stability control system that reduces variability to provide better CD control,
which results in higher wafer yields.
An intelligent imaging system for ArF scanner
Show abstract
The k1 factor continues to be driven downwards, even beyond its theoretical limit 0.25, in order to enable the 32 nm
feature generation and beyond. Due to the extremely small process-window that will be available for such extremely
demanding imaging challenges, it is necessary that not only each unit contributing to the imaging system be driven to its
ultimate performance capability, but also that the final integrated imaging system apply each of the different
components in an optimum way with respect to one another, and maintain that optimum performance level and
cooperation at all times. Components included in such an integrated imaging system include the projection lens,
illumination optics, light source, in-situ metrology tooling, aberration control, and dose control. In this paper we are
going to discuss the required functions of each component of the imaging system and how to optimally control each unit
in cooperation with the others in order to achieve the goal of 32 nm patterning and beyond.
Lithography Tools II
In-situ polarimetry of illumination for 193-nm lithography
Show abstract
Ellipsometry is defined as a technique for determining the properties of a bulk material or a thin film, such as optical
index and thickness, from the measurement of a polarization state of a reflected light or a change of polarization states
between the incident and reflected lights. On the other hand, polarimetry is defined as a technique for determining a
polarization state of a light. In other words, ellipsometry uses polarization as a probe and polarimetry measures
polarization itself.
We have constructed a theory of polarimetry of illumination used in lithography equipments, fabricated a polarimeter
mask, and demonstrated it for a hyper-NA (numerical aperture) immersion lithography scanner. The polarimeter mask
comprises polarizers and quarter-wave (λ/4) plates that are crammed into a narrow space with a height of 6.35 mm. The
thin plate polarizers available at a wavelength of 193 nm are made of calcite, and the λ/4-plates insensitive to angle of
incidence are made of four thin plates, two of which are crystalline quartz; the other two are sapphire. A light traveling
through a window of the polarimeter mask reaches an image detector at the wafer level through projection optics. Stokes
parameters of the illumination light can be measured without any influence from polarization characteristics of the
projection optics between the mask and the image detector.
Understanding illumination effects for control of optical proximity effects (OPE)
Show abstract
Optical lithography has had great success in recent history in utilizing the most advanced optical technology to create
NA=1.35 immersion lenses. These lenses have aberration levels at or below the 5m level. Much of this is due to
advancements in lens design, materials, and aspheric polishing techniques. Now that the lenses are nearly "perfect",
more attention is being given to the illuminator and its performance. This paper examines the fundamental metrics that
are used to analyze the illumination source shape as it pertains to the optical proximity effect (OPE). It is found that the
more traditional metric of partial coherence, σ, is often not sufficient to explain through pitch CD performance. Metrics
are introduced to compare multiple sources and compared to their correlation to OPE with respect to a reference. A new
parametric model for annular illumination is introduced and shown to correlate within an RMS=0.03nm of the OPE data.
Thermal aberration control in projection lens
Show abstract
In order to respond to the constant demand for more productivity in the manufacture of IC devices, higher throughput
and higher resolution are fundamental requirements for each new generation of exposure tools. However, meeting both
requirements lead to unwanted aberration we refer to as "thermal aberration". In our experience, the problem of the
thermal aberrations does not correlated only to the duration of heavy use. It depends very strongly on both the optical
settings and the mask patterns, also even on the specific interaction between the two. So, even if using the same
illumination configurations, there is a possibility to observe different distribution of thermal aberrations. In this paper,
we define and investigate various patterns to be used as targets for thermal aberrations compensation. These patterns are
identified as the "weak patterns" of the thermal aberration. We assess several cases of thermal aberrations, and show
how the optimized compensation for each is determined and then applied on the actual exposure tools.
Imaging performance optimization for hyper-NA scanner systems in high volume production
Show abstract
The introduction of lithographic systems with NA=1.35 has enabled the extension of optical lithography to 45 nm and
below. At the same time, despite the larger NA, k1-factors have dropped to 0.3 and below. Defining the appropriate
strategies for these high-end lithographic processes requires the integration and co-optimization of the design, mask and
imaging parameters. This requires an in-depth understanding of the relevant parameters for imaging performance during
high volume manufacturing.
Besides the Critical Dimension Uniformity (CDU) budget for the baseline lithographic system, it is crucial to realize that
system performance may vary over time in volume manufacturing.
In this paper the CDU budget will be restated, with all the well-known contributors, and extended with some new terms,
such as volume manufacturing effects.
Experimental low-k1 results will be shown from NA=1.35 lithographic tools and compared to model-based predictions
under realistic volume manufacturing circumstances.
The combination of extreme NA and low k1 makes it necessary to introduce computational lithography for scanner
optimization. The potential of using LithoCruiserTM and TachyonTM for optimising scanner source and OPC will be
described. Also, using the fast scanner correction mechanisms to compensate for reticle, track and etch fingerprints and
variations will be discussed.
Monitoring polarization at 193nm high-numerical aperture with phase shift masks: experimental results and industrial outlook
Show abstract
This paper will provide experimental results of Phase-Shift Mask (PSM) Polarimetry, a previously introduced resistbased
polarization monitoring technique that employs a specialized chromeless phase-shifting test reticle. The patterns
derived from high-NA proximity effects have proven to be 2 to 3 times more sensitive to polarization than a previously
reported generation of patterns. Example results in this paper show that for a numerical aperture (NA) of 0.93, this
technique is likely capable of measuring the intensity in the preferred polarization state (IPS) to within about 3%. Data
from a follow-on reticle for NAs up to 1.35 is expected soon and promises to measure IPS to within about 1.5%. This is
expected to suffice for monitoring polarization at the 22nm node for water-based immersion tools over time or from tool
to tool. This technique is extendable and likely offers even greater sensitivity for high-index immersion lithography,
should NAs greater than 1.35 become available. Advantages and disadvantages of this technique will be addressed.
Poster Session: Double Masking
A comprehensive comparison between double patterning and double patterning with spacer on sub-50nm product implementation
Show abstract
In this study, DP (Double Patterning) and DPS (Double Patterning with Spacer) were comprehensively compared through word line layout of 50nm node product, and special focus was put on the assessments of layout discontinuity zones through experimental validation. In conventional flash manufacturing, the lithographic proximity effect and etch loading effect around the array-gap zones have been inherent characteristics to be addressed. For DP process, apart from the overlay error induced pattern displacement and CD non-uniformity, the cross-coupling effects between adjacent features around the array-gap zones by two photo and two etch steps have further complicated the process optimization, therefore careful exploration was carried out to indicate the challenges on process optimization. The DPS can maintain good resultant CD uniformity of dense array through precisely programmed exposure CD and spacer thickness, it may also keep away from the proximity around array-gap zones. But, the second exposure is necessary for trimming the unwanted patterns and delineating the peripheral patterns. In purpose of trimming the unwanted patterns at array-gap zone in the 2nd exposure, the overlay registration will account for the CD control of boundary lines as well as the defectivity around this area.
100 nm half–pitch double exposure KrF lithography using binary masks
Show abstract
In this paper we investigate the process margin for the 100nm half - pitch double exposure KrF lithography using binary
masks for different illumination settings.
The application of Double Exposure Lithography (DEL) would enlarge the capability of 248 nm exposure technique to
smaller pitch e.g. for the integration of dedicated layers into 0.13 μm BiCMOS with critical dimension (CD)
requirements exceeding the standard 248 nm lithography specification. The DEL was carried out with a KrF Scanner
(Nikon S207D, NALens = 0.82) for a critical dimension (CD) of 100nm half pitch. The chemical amplified positive resists
SL4800 or UV2000 (Rohm & Haas) with a thickness of 325nm were coated on a 70 nm AR10L (Rohm & Haas) bottom
anti-reflective coating (BARC). With a single exposure and using binary masks it is not possible to resolve 100nm lines
with a pitch of 200 nm, due to the refraction and the resolution limit.
First we investigated the effect of focus variation. It is shown that the focus difference of 1st and 2nd exposure is one
critical parameter of the DEL. This requires a good focus repeatability of the scanner. The depth of focus (DOF) of
360 nm with the coherence parameter σ = 0.4 was achieved for DEL with SL4800 resist. The influence of the better
resist resolution of UV2000 on the process window will be shown (DOF = 460 nm). If we change the focus of one of the
exposures the CD and DOF performance of spaces is reduced with simultaneous line position changing.
Second we investigated the effect of different illumination shapes and settings. The results for conventional illumination
with different values for σ and annular illumination with σinner = 0.57 and σouter = 0.85 will be shown.
In summary, the results show that DEL has the potential to be a practical lithography enhancement method for device
fabrication using high NA KrF tool generation.
Double patterning using dual spin-on Si containing layers with multilayer hard mask process
Show abstract
A new technology called the double patterning (DP) process with ArF immersion lithography is one of the candidate
fabrication technologies for 32 nm-node devices. Over the past few years, many studies have been conducted on
techniques for the DP process. Among these technologies, we thought that the double Si hard mask (HM) process is the
most applicable technology from the viewpoint of high technical applicability to 32 nm-node device fabrication.
However, this process has a disadvantage in the cost performance compared with other DP technologies since these HMs
are formed by the chemical vacuum deposition (CVD) method.
In this paper, we studied the DP process using a dual spin-on Si containing layer without using the CVD method to
improve process cost and process applicability. Perhydropolysilazane (PSZ) was used as one of the middle layers (MLs).
PSZ changes to SiO2 through the reaction with water by the catalytic action of amine in the baking step. Using PSZ and
Si-BARC as MLs, we succeeded in making a fine pattern by this novel DP technique. In this paper, the issues and
countermeasures of the double HM technique using spin-on Si containing layers will be reported.
45nm and 32nm half-pitch patterning with 193nm dry lithography and double patterning
Show abstract
Double patterning technique is listed as the top option for 32nm technology nodes at recently updated 2007 International
Technology Roadmap Semiconductor (ITRS). Double patterning (DP) effectively reduces the k1 factor to less than 0.25,
however, various process challenges, including critical dimension uniformity (CDU), line edge and line width
roughnesses (LER/LWR), and overlay, have to come up with solutions for the industry in device manufacturing. In this
study, we developed a metal hard mask and a universal dual hard mask double patterning process and demonstrated
45nm half-pitch in dark field patterning and 32nm half pitch in bright field applications by using a 0.93NA 193nm dry
scanner system. By using the optimized hard mask films and Applied Materials' Advanced Patterning Film (APFTM) as a
bottom hard mask, the universal dual hard mask double patterning scheme shows significant improvement in line edge
roughness and line width roughness, achieved best results of 2nm LER and 2.5nm LWR at APF hard mask.
A new OPC method for double patterning technology
Show abstract
As the VLSI technology scales into deep submicron nodes, Double Patterning Technology (DPT) has shown its necessity
for the under 45nm processes. However, the litho-related and process-related issues, such as the overlay control for CD
uniformity, decomposition, feature stitching technology and some other problems make up the main challenges for the
implementation of DPT. Due to Optical Proximity Correction (OPC), the complexity and data volume of DPT increase
dramatically, which severely increase the application cost and create manufacturability problems.
In this paper, we mainly talk about the interactions between DPT and OPC and propose a new Model-Based OPC
methods for the decomposition in DPT procedures. To address the printing problems with cutting sites for feature split,
we introduce an overlap correction method on the stitching locations. For any re-cut and/or redesigned pattern after
verification, we categorize DP decompositions and introduce a new Adaptable OPC (Ad-OPC) algorithm by reusing post
OPC layout to speed up the correction and improve its convergence according to environment surrounding. The method
can be easily incorporated into existing MB-OPC framework. To test this method, total Edge Placement Error (EPE) and
runtime are calculated in our experiments. Results show that over 90% runtime can be saved compared with
conventional OPC procedure. It increases the robustness and friendliness of pattern correction as well as stitches features
back satisfactorily.
Study of ELS technology for random logic LSI toward 32-nm node
Show abstract
There has been an ongoing request to make semiconductor devices smaller and smaller. The cellblock size
of SRAM is predominated by both a gate-to-contact space and a poly-to-poly space. The gate-to-contact space is
defined by the leakage value from the poly electrode. So we focused on the poly-to-poly space for all shrinkage.
We have been studying connected line splitting techniques. We named it ELS (end of line splitting)
technology. A critical issue is to control gaps between two narrow gate-poly's line-ends or between a narrow gatepoly's
line-end and a neighboring wire-poly line due to lower contrast in low-k1 lithography. In the case of standard
cells, especially, the patterning of narrow gate-poly projected to wire-poly is easy to shorten. To prevent this electrical
short, designers avoid keeping a narrow gap and small chip size. In order to realize a narrower gap, a splitting
technique, well-known and adopted in poly's line-ends of SRAM that are regularly arrayed, is effective. We are
investigating how to extend this technique as ELS technology for random logic of poly toward creating a 32-nm node.
In this paper, the authors focus on the following topics: 1) data preparation technique, and 2) experimental
results. Then this technology for the poly layer of random logic LSI devices is compared with result of conventional
single exposure and double pattering technology. In addition, the result that overlay control issue for ELS technology is
not severe compared with pitch doubling technology is described. ELS technology can help the designer and our
lithographer to reduce the gap and reduce the array grid size of standard cells.
Double patterning in lithography for 65nm node with oxidation process
Show abstract
Recently, in order to increase the number of transistors in wafer by small feature size, optical lithography has
been changed to low wavelength from 365nm to 193nm and high NA of 0.93. And further wavelength is aggressively
shifting to 13.5nm for more small feature size, i.e., Extreme Ultra Violet Lithography(EUVL), a kind of Next Generation
Lithography(NGL)1. And other technologies are developed such as water immersion(193nm) and photo resist Double
Patterning(DP). Immersion lens system has high NA up to 1.3 due to high n of water(n=1.44 at 193nm), the parameter k1
is process constant, but 0.25 is a tough limit at a equal line and space, if we use immersion lens with 193nm wavelength
than limit of resolution is 37nm. Especially, Double Exposure Technique(DET) process is widely studied because of the
resolution enhancement ability using a same material and machine, despite of process complication. And SADP(Self
Aligned Double Patten) is newly researched for overlay and LER(Line Edge Roughness) enhancement.
In this paper, we illustrate the feasibility of the shift double pattern for 65nm-node flash using a 193nm light
dipole source and the possibility of decrease minimum feature size using a property of silicon shrinkage during thermal
oxidation process.
Precise CD control techniques for double patterning and sidewall transfer
Show abstract
We have successfully developed a self-limiting chemical dry etch process, associated equipment, and process flow
featuring no use of plasma and no mask bending. In this process and process flow, the system performs mask trimming
for critical dimension (CD) adjustments after hard-mask formation. First, the CD as defined in lithography is directly
transferred by reactive ion etching (RIE) to silicon oxide film that is to become the hard mask. Next, reactive gas is
deposited on the surface of the silicon oxide film at low temperatures and the reaction product is evaporated at high
temperatures. With this process flow, there is no need to trim a mask made of organic materials. As a result, there is no
mask bending and the amount of hard-mask trimming can be set by the amount of gas flow and pressure in the chemical
dry etch process enabling detailed CD control to be performed. The proposed technology means that even higher aspect
ratios in masks and finer CD control can be achieved for processes such as double patterning (DP) and sidewall transfer
(SWT).
Fabrication of contact/via holes for 32-nm technology device using cost-effective RIE CD shrink process and double patterning technique
Show abstract
We have developed a cost-effective critical dimension (CD) shrink technique that allows all-in-one processing of CD
shrinking, BARC etching, hard mask etching, and resist stripping in a reactive ion etcher (RIE) for the double patterning
(DP) required in the formation of contact and via hole masks with the most critical exposure margins. This CD shrink
technique was successfully applied to achieve a CD shrinkage of 60 nm and a CD uniformity of within 3 nm at 3 sigma
over the wafer surface. We also determined that the CD shrink technique that employs RIE differs from CD shrink by
resolution enhancement lithography assisted by chemical shrink (RELACS) [1] and low-temperature molecular layer
deposition (MLD) in having an effect of expanding the lithography process window. We successfully applied our
technique to form a 30-nm CD hole pattern with a duty ratio of 1:1.
Double patterning overlay and CD budget for 32 nm technology node
Show abstract
Double patterning is the best technique which allows 193nm immersion lithography to anticipate the 32 nm node, before
EUV lithography. The final device pattern is formed by two independent patterning steps where the dense pitch is
doubled. This allows printing each patterning step with higher k1 imaging factor.
In this paper we present the overlay and CD budget applied to a double patterning (DP) technique for the definition of a
32nm technology node device, using an immersion scanner tool. A balance among different factors which affects the
final CD of the device is necessary to optimize the imaging and the alignment performances of the exposure tool. A
preliminary activity is also necessary to choose the most suitable mask splitting strategy. Adopting a single mask, which
is exposed twice with the appropriate shift - the final pitch - , makes the overlay between the two exposures less critical
than splitting the complementary layouts on two different masks. Finally, the CD uniformity of the pooled distributions
from the two exposures is evaluated in order to define the requested tool performances in terms of overlay, CD control
and metrology.
Double exposure double etch for dense SRAM: a designer's dream
Show abstract
As SRAM arrays become lithographically more aggressive than random logic, they are more and more
determining the lithography processes used. High yielding, low leakage, dense SRAM cells demand fairly
aggressive lithographic process conditions. This leads to a borderline process window for logic devices.
The tradeoff obtained between process window optimization for random logic gates and dense SRAM is
not always straightforward, and sometimes necessitates design rule and layout modifications. By delinking
patterning of the logic devices from SRAM, one can optimize the patterning processes for these devices
independently. This can be achieved by a special double patterning technique that employs a combination
of double exposure and double etch (DE2). In this paper we show how a DE2 patterning process can be
employed to pattern dense SRAM cells in the 45nm node on fully integrated wafers, with more than
adequate overlap of gate line-end onto active area. We have demonstrated that this process has adequate
process window for sustainable manufacturing. For comparison purpose we also demonstrate a single
exposure single etch solution to treat such dense SRAM cells. In 45nm node, the dense SRAM cell can also
be printed with adequate tolerances and process window with single expose (SE) with optimized OPC. This
is confirmed by electrical results on wafer. We conclude that DE2 offers an attractive alternative solution to
pattern dense SRAM in 45nm and show such a scheme can be extended to 32nm and beyond. Employing
DE2 lets designers migrate to very small tip-to-tip distance in SRAM. The selection of DE2 or SE depends
on layout, device performance requirements, integration schemes and cost of ownership.
An analysis of double exposure lithography options
Show abstract
The current optical photolithography technology is approaching the physical barrier to the minimum achievable
feature size. To produce smaller devices, new resolution enhancement technologies must be developed. Double
exposure lithography has shown promise as potential pathway that is attractive because it is much cheaper than
double patterning lithography and it can be deployed on existing imaging tools. However, this technology is not
possible without the development of new materials with nonlinear response to exposure dose. The performance
of existing materials such as reversible contrast enhancement layers (rCELs) and theoretical materials such as intermediate
state two-photon (ISTP) and optical threshold layer (OTL) materials in double exposure applications
was investigated through computer simulation. All three materials yielded process windows in double exposure
mode. OTL materials showed the largest process window (DOF 0.137 μm, EL 5.06 %). ISTP materials had the
next largest process window (DOF 0.124 μm, EL 3.22 %) followed by the rCEL (0.105 μm, 0.58 %). This study
is an analysis of the feasibility of using the materials in double exposure mode.
Double printing through the use of ion implantation
Show abstract
Argon ion implantation has been investigated as a means of achieving resist stabilization, such that a
second resist layer may be patterned without attacking the 1st layer. The viability of such an
approach has been investigated for double printing. Potential benefits include resist feature shrinkage
and Line Width Roughness (LWR) improvements. Line shrinkage benefits the lithographic process
window as features can be printed larger, while improvements in LWR, is a further valuable
attribute. We report on the role played by ion implant dose, its impact on both lateral and vertical
resist shrinkage, LWR as well as its impact on organic BARC reflectivity. The performance of such
masks during dry etching of a gate layer has been additionally evaluated.
30nm half-pitch metal patterning using Moti CD shrink technique and double patterning
Show abstract
Double patterning lithography appears a likely candidate to bridge the gap between water-based immersion lithography
and EUV. A double patterning process is discussed for 30nm half-pitch interconnect structures, using 1.2 NA immersion
lithography combined with the MotifTM CD shrink technique. An adjusted OPC calculation is required to model the
proximity effects of the Motif shrink technique and subsequent metal hard mask (MHM) etch, on top of the lithography
based proximity effects. The litho-etch-litho-etch approach is selected to pattern a TiN metal hard mask. This mask is
then used to etch the low-k dielectric. The various process steps and challenges encountered are discussed, with the
feasibility of this approach demonstrated by successfully transferring a 30nm half-pitch pattern into the MHM.
Enabling 35nm double patterning contact imaging using a novel CD shrink process
Show abstract
With 32nm and 22nm feature size node in the near future, Double patterning type processing will be in
mainstream device manufacturing in most cutting edge Fabrication facilities. These type of processes
requires cooperation between the litho cell and the other processing modules. In a collaboration
between ASML and TEL we have developed a integrated solution to image 30nm Contacts. We
describe a novel technique to achieve a geometric shrink from a starting geometry of 65nm down to the
final feature size of 30nm for each of the two contact images Processing 2 images separately could
produce two distinct populations for alignment and critical dimensions. We will show the ability to
image 65nm contacts on a 130nm pitch with acceptable process windows and then apply the novel CD
shrink process to shrink the 65nm contacts to 30nm final dimension. The second level of contacts is
imaged in between the 1st set of contacts allowing us to image a 32nm ½ pitch contact pattern.
We show the ability to Image 2 separate sets of contacts using a split clip layout with a single
distribution for critical output parameters. We address the following process challenges:
1) Overlay capability across the slit and across the field.
2) Critical Dimension capability across the slit and across the Field.
3) Sidewall angle integrity with acceptable process window.
Using the novel CD shrink process TEL has developed and imaging capability of the an ASML 1700i
TWINSCAN, we can achieve a double pattern contact process with acceptable process capability.
Poster Session: High Index Immersion Lithography
Prediction of imaging performance of immersion lithography using high refractive index fluid
Show abstract
A hyper-NA lithography tool is used in production of the latest devices. In the next generation immersion lithography,
issues that had so for neglected had to be considered because NA of illumination optics is larger than conventional tools.
Here, items were listed up for accurate prediction of imaging by optical simulation. These were transmittance of
illumination rays to the mask, mask induced effects such as polarization and aberration, and pellicle induced effect. These
were depending on incident angle. Therefore consideration of angle dependency of these effects was necessary for more
accurate imaging simulation. We presented the requirements for simulation to facilitate discussion of the imaging
performance of below 40 nm hp pattern node immersion lithography.
Contrast management of 193i interferometry to be close to scanners contrast conditions
Show abstract
When projected with a scanner, the latent image intensity in the photoresist has a slope that can be much lower than
with an interferometer. To study finely the lithographic process and to be predictive, the Normalized image slope of 193
nm immersion interferometer built at LETI has to be controlled. The exposure latitude (EL), the Normalized Image Log
Slope (NILS) and the interference contrast are closely related.
Immersion exposure system using high-index materials
Show abstract
ArF water immersion systems with a numerical aperture (NA) of over 1.3 have already introduced for the node up to 45-
nm half-pitch production. For the next generation of lithography, we focus on ArF immersion lithography using high-index
materials. At present, LuAG (n=2.14) is the most promising candidate as a high-index lens material. Second-generation
fluids (n=1.64) have the sufficient performance as a high-index immersion fluid. The combination of LuAG
and a second-generation fluid can enhance the NA up to 1.55 and the exposure system would be available for the 34-nm
half-pitch node when k1 is 0.27.
Although high-index immersion lithography is attractive since it is effective in raising resolution, there are some issues
not encountered in water immersion system. The issues of LuAG are its availability and the intrinsic birefringence.
Fluid degradation induced by dissolved oxygen or laser irradiation, lens contamination, and residual fluid on a wafer are
the specific issues of the immersion system.
In this article, we introduce the current status for the above issues and discuss the feasibility of ArF immersion system
using high-index materials.
Continuing 193nm optical lithography for 32nm imaging and beyond
Show abstract
The practical extendibility of immersion lithography to the 32nm and 22nm nodes is being supported on immersion
microsteppers installed at SEMATECH in Albany, New York. As the industry pushes the limits of water-based
immersion technologies, research has continued into developing alternative materials to extend optical lithography for
upcoming device generations. High index materials have been the primary focus of investigation, including optical lens
materials such as lutetium aluminum garnet (LuAG with n=2.14) and barium lithium fluoride (BaLiF3 with n=1.64),
high index fluids (Gen 2 and Gen 3 with n>=1.64), and resists. On a parallel and potentially complementary path,
double patterning and double exposure technologies have been proposed. For high index materials research, the
Amphibian XIS has demonstrated imaging at 1.50NA (32nm half-pitch) with high index fluids. A prism module is also
available to enable imaging with potential BaLiF3 and LuAG prisms. The Exitech MS193i has demonstrated
performance and imaging capability at 38nm hp with k1=0.256 at 1.30NA. Modifications at the mask plane now
provide a double exposure capability, offering an imaging platform to investigate experimental classes of nonlinear
materials and enabling double exposure imaging below k1eff=0.25. In this paper, we will discuss recent developments in
these research areas supported by the toolset at SEMATECH.
Poster Session: Lithography Tools
Novel refractive optics enable multipole off-axis illumination
Show abstract
Optical lithography in the deep ultraviolet (DUV) region is being pushed to reach the limits of printing resolution. The
effort required to achieve the 32 nm structure with this technology puts very hard conditions and requests on the
illumination optics. Different kinds of illumination modes are combined to get into a regime of extreme numerical
aperture (hyper NA). Arrays of refractive micro-optics have been and continue to be the ideal solution for high
transmission homogenizing elements for several tool generations.
Illumination of the masks with high numerical aperture is critical for achieving the smallest structure on the
semiconductor material. Exposure tools use different illumination modes to get better imaging of certain mask structures.
The beam shaping necessary to create these illumination modes is achieved mostly with diffractive elements. Most of the
currently used modes can also be created with arrays of refractive micro-optics, manufactured from fused silica and
calcium fluoride. The advantage over the diffractive optical elements lies in efficiency, which comes close to 90%.
An important prerequisite for these special types of optical elements is LIMO's unique production technology which can
manufacture free form surfaces on monolithic arrays exceeding 200 mm edge length with high precision and
reproducibility. These homogenizing elements in the illumination optics can provide a custom designed intensity
distribution, and offer the possibility to correct the failure of other optical elements. Each lens can be designed
individually and can also be shaped asymmetrically. Thus unusual lens sizes and shapes can be produced, and various far
fields such as rectangles, lines, hexagons or multi-poles can be achieved.
In this paper we present novel refractive micro-optical elements which create rectangular dipole illumination. They can
also be combined in such a way as to create a quadrupole with variable intensity ratio between the vertical and horizontal
poles. The huge advantage of such a multipole illumination is polarization control and variable intensity in poles. Working on this combination, the resolution can be enhanced even further.
45nm node logic device OPE matching between exposure tools through laser bandwidth tuning
Show abstract
For 45 nm Node logic devices, we have investigated the impact of laser bandwidth fluctuation on Optical Proximity
Effect (OPE) by evaluating variation in through-pitch critical dimension (CD) performance. In addition, from these
results we have calculated the Iso-Dense Bias (IDB), and determined the sensitivity to laser bandwidth fluctuation. These
IDB results also enable us to present the laser bandwidth stability that is required to maintain a constant OPE. And
finally, we introduce results from an investigation into OPE-matching between different generations of exposure tools,
whereby in addition to laser bandwidth control, tilt-scan methodology was employed.
Fluoride single crystals for the next generation lithography
Show abstract
BaLiF3 single crystal has been studied as the candidate for the last lens material of the next generation high index
immersion lithography system. Although the refractive index of BaLiF3 is 1.64 at 193nm which is not sufficient for the
requirement, other optical properties such as 193nm transparency and laser durability fulfill the requirement.
It is estimated that the cause of both high SBR part and inhomogeneity of refractive index of BaLiF3 seems to present
along the faces of slip planes which are observed by crossed Nicol observation. As a result of comparative study of
various direction perpendiculars to the growth axis, good crystallinity with less slip planes has been obtained by shifting
the growth axis from <100> which is adequate for the last lens production.
MgF2 single crystal studied as the polarizer material for high power ArF laser oscillator, and crystal with excellent
laser durability and large diameter (>100mm) has been developed by CZ technique. In addition crystals oriented along
both c-axis and a-axis were successfully grown.
An improved process for manufacturing diffractive optical elements (DOEs) for off-axis illumination systems
Show abstract
We present advancements in the manufacture of high-performance diffractive optical elements (DOEs) used in
stepper/scanner off-axis illumination systems. These advancements have been made by employing high resolution
lithographic techniques, in combination with precision glass-etching capabilities. Enhanced performance of DOE designs
is demonstrated, including higher efficiency with improved uniformity for multi-pole illumination at the pupil plane,
while maintaining low on-axis intensity.
Theoretical predictions of the performance for several classes of DOE designs will be presented and compared with
experimental results.
This new process capability results in improved performance of current DOE designs, and enables greater customization
including control of the output spatial intensity distribution for future designs. These advancements will facilitate
continuous improvements in off-axis illumination optimization required by the end user to obtain larger effective
lithographic process windows.
A novel photo-thermal setup for determination of absorptance losses and wavefront deformations in DUV optics
Show abstract
Lens heating due to absorbed UV laser radiation can diminish the achievable spatial resolution of
the lithographic process in semiconductor wafer steppers. At the Laser- Laboratorium Göttingen a
measurement system for quantitative registration of this thermal lens effect was developed. It is
based upon a strongly improved Hartmann-Shack wavefront sensor with extreme sensitivity,
accomplishing precise online monitoring of wavefront deformations of a collimated test laser beam
transmitted through the laser-irradiated site of a sample. Caused by the temperature-dependent
refractive index as well as thermal expansion, the formerly plane wavefront of the test laser is
distorted to form a rotationally symmetric valley, being equivalent to a convex lens. The observed
wavefront distortion is a quantitative measure of the absorption losses in the sample. Thermal
theory affords absolute calibration of absorption coefficients.
Performance demonstration of significant availability improvement in lithography light sources using GLX control system
Show abstract
Increasing productivity demands on leading-edge scanners require greatly improved light source availability. This
translates directly to minimizing downtime and maximizing productive time, as defined in the SEMI E10 standard.
Focused efforts to achieve these goals are ongoing and Cymer has demonstrated significant improvements on production
light sources.
This paper describes significant availability improvements of Cymer light sources enabled by a new advanced gas
management scheme called Gas Lifetime eXtensioTM (GLTM) control system. Using GLX, we have demonstrated the
capability of extending the pulse-based interval between full gas replenishments to 1 billion pulses on our XLA light
sources, as well as significant extension in the time-based interval between refills. This represents a factor of 10X
increase in the maximum interval between full gas replenishments, which equates to potential gain of up to 2% in
productive time over a year for systems operating at high utilization.
In this paper, we provide performance data on extended (1 billion pulse) laser operation without full gas replenishment
under multiple actual practical production environments demonstrating the ability to achieve long gas lives with very
stable optical performance from the laser system. In particular, we have demonstrated that GLX can provide excellent
stability in key optical performance parameters, such as bandwidth, over extended gas lives. Further, these stability
benefits can be realized under both high and low pulse accumulation scenarios.
In addition, we briefly discuss the potential for future gas management enhancements that will provide even longer term
system performance stability and corresponding reductions in tool downtime.
Reliable high power injection locked 6 kHz 60W laser for ArF immersion lithography
Show abstract
The Argon Fluoride (ArF) immersion lithography is now shifting to mass production phase for below 45nm node. For a
laser light source in this node, narrower and more stable spectrum performance is required. We have introduced GT61A
ArF laser light source (60W/6kHz/10mJ/0.35pm) with spectrum E95 stabilization system which meets these
requirements. The narrow and stabilized spectrum performance was achieved by developing an ultra line narrowing
module and Bandwidth Control Module (BCM). It contributes to the reduction of differences of the spectrum during
exposure over a wafer, wafer to wafer, during machine lifetime and machine to machine for every light source. Stable
laser performance is obtained for mass production. The GT61A integrated on a common and already reliability-proven
GigaTwin (GT) platform, and its inherited reliability is proved with the availability over 99.5% in the field.
High-power and high-energy stability injection lock laser light source for double exposure or double patterning ArF immersion lithography
Show abstract
ArF immersion technology is spotlighted as the enabling technology for below 45nm node. Recently, double exposure
technology is also considered for below 32nm node. We have already released an injection lock ArF excimer laser with
ultra-line narrowed and stabilized spectrum performance: GT61A (60W/6kHz/ 10mJ/0.35pm) to ArF immersion market
in Q4 2006. The requirements are: i) higher power ii) lower cost of downtime for higher throughput iii) greater
wavelength stability for improved overlay and iv) increased lifetimes for lower operation costs.
We have developed high power and high energy stability injection lock ArF excimer laser for double patterning: GT62A
(90W/6000Hz/15mJ/0.35pm) based on the technology of GT61A and the reliability of GigaTwin (GT) platform. A high
power operation of 90W is realized by development of high durability optical elements. Durability of the new optics is at
least 3 times as long as that of the conventional optics used in the GT61A. The energy stability is improved more than
1.5 times of performance in the GT61A by optimizing laser operational conditions of the power oscillator. This
improvement is accomplished by extracting potential efficiency of injection lock characteristic. The lifetime of power
oscillator, which is one of the major parts in cost of ownership, is maintained by using higher output of the power supply.
Uniaxial crystal last optical element for second- and third-generation immersion lithography
Show abstract
In this paper, we show that uniaxial crystals and sapphire in particular, can be used as a lens material for high-index
immersion lithography. Although uniaxial crystals are birefringent and anisotropic for unpolarized light, under certain
conditions they are fully isotropic for transverse electric (TE) polarizations. The strong birefringence of the uniaxial
crystal defocuses the residual TM polarization relative to the TE mode so that its image does not reach the photoresist
but rather creates a small background. To manifest this property, a combination of pupil-fill polarization constraints,
mask design rules and crystal alignment requirements must be satisfied. Sapphire is a well-known industrial optical
material featuring high optical quality and homogeneity. Its refractive index of 1.928 at 193 nm, along with its high
thermal conductivity and moderate absorption, are close to industry requirements. An implementation of sapphire under
these conditions is proposed, suggesting a path to the continued scaling of 193 nm lithography numerical aperture.
Poster Session: Low-k1 Lithography
Impact of optimization conditions on the result at optimizing illumination and mask
Show abstract
Illumination for SRAM device pattern with peripheral circuit is optimized applying OPC during optimization. At first the
memory cell is targeted, next library patterns that represent the peripheral circuit are added as the targets one by one, and
it is investigated how the optimized illumination varies. As optimized targets ILS and dose-focus window are used. For
the case of ILS the optimized illumination shapes become milder as more patterns are evaluated and the OPC result
becomes weaker correspondingly. For the case of window the tendency is similar but not so intense. The illuminations
optimized by ILS and window are different. The optimized illuminations by optical and resist simulation are a little
different. As practical application illumination defined by functions such as annular is evaluated, where the information
of actual scanners are applied. At first 1/4 divided polarization plate is used instead of tangential polarization. Secondly
illumination is searched in the solution space that consists of hardware design instead of numerical expression. By
introducing the information the optimized illuminations are varied. From these results it turns out that the optimization
tool should handle the information of actual scanners properly. And we have developed the solution tool (k1-TUNE).
Understanding and application of constructive, destructive SRAF
Show abstract
Acceptance of Sub Resolution Assist Feature (SRAF) has been widely recognized in lithography patterning. In general,
with the insertion of SRAF in optically adjacent space area of design main feature, the aerial image intensity profiles of
the corresponding main features are apparently being either constructively or destructively alternated at imaging plane
[Figure 1]. From lithography patterning perspective, the optimized or better pattern imaging process requires
constructive SRAF. Such SRAF is inserted into available space for main feature to obtain optimal or better image
contrast, better imaging resolution and depth of focus (DOF) which is similar or close to optimal focus latitude.
However, the complementary destructive SRAF insertion can adversely occur in certain circumstances. In this paper, we
study the theoretical understanding of the constructive and destructive effects against design main features imaging
associated with the efforts to include SRAF (it's either driven by rule, model or mishap). In addition, an evaluation
scheme is developed and being explored in many aspects in order to describe the constructive and destructive response of
inserted SRAF. Such evaluation scheme has derived an application to detect the degree of SRAF insertion coverage
accuracy, impact on manufacturing, and most usefully, to access potential layout required optimization in design space
based on these complementary effects mechanism throughout several off-axis illumination conditions.
eature
90nm node contact hole patterning through applying model based OPC in KrF lithography
Show abstract
As semiconductor technologies move toward 90nm generation and below, contact hole is one of the most challenging
features to print in the semiconductor manufacturing process. There are two principal difficulties in order to define small
contact hole pattern on wafer. One is insufficient process margin besides poor resolution compared with line & space
pattern. The other is that contact hole should be made through pitches and sometimes random contact hole pattern should
be fabricated. Therefore advanced ArF lithography scanner should be used for small contact hole printing with RETs
(Resolution Enhancement Techniques) such as immersion lithography, OPC(Optical Proximity Correction), PSM(Phase
Shift Mask), high NA(Numerical Aperture), OAI(Off-Axis Illumination), SRAF(Sub-resolution Assistant Feature), mask
biasing and thermal flow. Like this, ArF lithography propose the method of enhancing resolution, however, we must
spend an enormous amount of CoC(cost of ownership) to utilize ArF photolithography process than KrF.
In this paper, we suggest the method of contact holes patterning by using KrF lithography tool in 90nm sFlash(stand
alone Flash)devices. For patterning of contact hole, we apply RETs which combine OAI and Model based OPC.
Additionally, in this paper we present the result of hole pattern images which operate ArF lithography equipment. Also,
this study describes comparison of two wafer images that ArF lithography process which is used mask biasing and Rule
based OPC, KrF lithography process which is applied hybrid OPC.
Manufacturing implementation of 32nm SRAM using ArF immersion with RET
Show abstract
As the pattern size shrinking down below 1/4 of the exposure wavelength, the NA of exposure tool has to be increased
proportionally. The use of hyper NA and immersion exposure system for improving image quality may result in a
small workable process window. Hence, resolution enhancement technology (RET) becomes a necessity for
semiconductor manufacturing. Previous studies have demonstrated many RETs, such as CPL, DDL, IML and DPT etc.
can improve the process window for different applications.1,2,3,4 In this work, we show manufacturing
implementation of a 32nm node SRAM cell with different RET approaches. The diffusion, poly, contact, and metal
layers were chosen as the target design. The process development project starts from the wafer exposure scheme
setting, which includes the multi-exposure, illumination shape and mask type. After the RET has been specified, the
process performance indexes, such as MEEF, PW, and CDU are characterized by using both simulation and empirical
data.
The mask design and OPC is implemented After the mask data preparation step, we then optimize exposure
parameters for best printing performance and follow it by verifying actual wafer data. The mask making spec and
DFM design rule constrains have been assessed and recommended for 32nm node manufacturing. Also, we have
examined the immersion process defect impact and control methodology for production environment. In this paper,
we report the result of optimizing RET process (including mask data generation, reticle making specifications, and
wafer printing) for 32nm SRAM. With 193nm ultra high NA immersion exposure scanner (such as ASML /1900), it
is capable of meeting 32nm SRAM manufacturing requirement.
Random 65nm..45nm C/H printing using optimized illumination source and CD sizing by post processing
Show abstract
Printing random Contact Holes (C/H) is one of the most difficult tasks in current low-k1 lithography. Different
approaches have been proposed and demonstrated successfully. One approach is the use of extensive Resolution
Enhancement Technique such as sub-resolution assisting features, focus drilling and interference mapping lithography in
combination with strong off-axis illumination. These techniques often lead to enhanced complexity at the OPC and mask
making side. In order to keep the complexity low, soft illumination modes have been proposed like Soft-Annular (bull'seye)
and Soft-Quasar type illumination [1]. It has been shown that the minimum k1 for the latter route is k1=0.41 using
experimental results up to 0.93 NA. In this paper we demonstrate that the latter route can be extended to 45nm C/H at a
minimum pitch of 120nm when using 1.35 NA. In order to achieve this we additionally applied a CD sizing technique to
create the very small C/H.
Study of SRAF placement for contact at 45 nm and 32 nm node
Show abstract
At 45 and 32 nm nodes, one of the most critical layers is the Contact one. Due to the use of hyper NA imaging, the
depth of focus starts to be very limited.
Moreover the OPC is rapidly limited because of the increase of the pattern density. The limited surface in the dark field
region of a Contact layer mask enforces the edges movement to stop very quickly.
The use of SRAF (Sub Resolution Assist Feature) has been widely use for DOF enhancement of line and space layers
since many technology node. Recently, SRAF generated using inverse lithography have shown interesting DOF
improvement1. However, the advantage of the ideal mask generated by inverse lithography is lost when switching to a
manufacturable mask with Manhattan structures. For SRAF placed in rule based as well as Manhattan SRAF generated
after inverse lithography, it is important to know what their behavior is, in term of size and placement.
In this article we propose to study the placement of scatter-trenches assist features for the contact layer. For this we have
performed process window simulation with different SRAF sizes and distance to the main OPC. These results permit us
to establish the trends for size and placement of the SRAF.
Moreover we have also take a look of the advantages of using 8 surrounding SRAF (4 in vertical - horizontal and 4 at
45°) versus 4 surrounding SRAF. Based on these studies we have seen that there is no real gain of increasing the
complexity by adding additional SRAF.
Automated method of detecting SRAF and sidelobe printing with automated CD-SEM recipes
Show abstract
In development of optical proximity correction (OPC) for new technology nodes, optimization of assist features requires
multiple placement scenarios for each line/space or hole combination. Additionally, illumination and process conditions
are varied to determine the optimal process window. Under some illumination and process conditions, optimal printing
of the desired features is attained; however, undesired printing of sidelobes or sub-resolution assist features (SRAFs) also
occurs. Currently, CD sizes are measured for the desired feature and images are hand checked for unwanted features
(sidelobe or SRAF printing). This takes a large amount of time, given the hundreds to thousands of CDSEM
measurements required to generate a given OPC model. This problem is multiplied if several passes of data collection
are needed to optimize each OPC model and each layer. An automated method has been developed to quickly screen a
large number of SEM images for unwanted features, and if they exist, flag the measurement point so it can be easily
identified as an undesirable area of the process window. This method employs edge placement measurement capabilities
available with automated SEM recipe generation software to identify the presence of an unwanted feature within a given
image. A simple Boolean filter is used to exclude this process area as SRAF or sidelobe printing process space so it may
be excluded from the OPC model and from the operational process space. This automated method for identification of
SRAFs or sidelobes provides significant engineering time savings and allows characterization of the onset of undesirable
features to assist in optimization of OPC within a given process window.
Novel lithography rule check for full-chip side lobe detection
Show abstract
Attenuated PSM (Phase Shift Mask) has been widely adopted in contact lithography to enhance the resolution and process latitude. While the main drawback associated with the use of attenuated PSM is the side lobe printing, which yields unwanted resist erosion of area among patterned holes. Side lobes, if etched and filled in the following semiconductor processing, can cause electrical shorting, chip failure and device reliability problem, hence any side lobes are extremely undesirable. Usually, the side lobe detection for simple layouts can be conducted manually through the help of lithography simulation tools, but the detection of potential side lobe printing becomes far more challenging for full-chip production layouts. An efficient side-lobe detection approach was demonstrated in this study, with the use of assistant ring, polygon-based simulation instead of grid-based simulation has been enabled for full-chip side lobe detection. Furthermore, a model-based method for side lobe suppression was also demonstrated in our flow.
Quasi-iso-focal hole pattern formation by Checker-Board PSM (CB-PSM)
Show abstract
A novel RET, which enables on-grid sub-50 nm hole pattern formation with ArF immersion lithography, has been
developed. One of the authors has found quasi-iso-focal point image generation at the center of square area of high
transmission embedded attenuating phase shift mask (EA-PSM), where four small openings are laid out at the corners of
the area, utilizing an optimized quadrupole illumination. As an extension of continuous configuration, checker-board
like mask pattern arrangement is created. In the mask, small openings and opaque pads are arranged like as checkerboard,
whose base pitch is around resolution limit of targeted optical system. The mask pattern arrangement is named as
"Checker-Board PSM (CB-PSM)". By eliminating any one opening from "checker-board", very fine point image is
generated at the place. Because four openings around the eliminated one are necessary for the fine imaging
characteristic, minimum distance between the point images is about the double of that for resolution limit. After
simulation study of imaging, experiments are carried out to prove the fine imaging performance utilizing ArF immersion
optics with NA=1.07 and a tri-level resist system. As a result, sub-50nm isolated hole is successfully formed with DOF
larger than 200 nm. Simultaneously, ~ 60 nm semi-dense hole with pitch of 240 nm is printed with over 200 nm DOF.
Moreover, application of conventional mask pattern arrangement, ultimately dense hole of 140nm pitch is well formed.
As a conclusion, we believe that CB-PSM is a promising candidate for hole pattern formation at 32 nm node and beyond.
Optimum biasing for 45 nm node chromeless and attenuated phase shift mask
Show abstract
Resolution enhancement technology (RET) refers to a technique that extends the usable resolution of an imaging
system without decreasing the wavelength of light or increasing the numerical aperture (NA) of the imaging tool. Offaxis
illumination (OAI) and a phase shift mask (PSM) are essentially accompanied by optical proximity correction
(OPC) for semiconductor device manufacturing nowadays. A chromeless PSM (CLM or CPL) is compared to an
attenuated PSM (att.PSM) to make 45 nm dense line and space pattern. To obtain the best possible resolution, a proper
OPC is required with CPL and the most common application of OPC technique is the use of space bias. The optical
system with a high numerical aperture (NA), a strong OAI, and a proper polarization can decrease the k1 value well
below 0.3. CPL has various advantages over alternating PSM such as no necessity of double exposure, small pattern
displacement, and no CD error caused by the intensity imbalance. But CPL has some disadvantages. In the case of 100 %
transmittance pure CPL, there is no shading material that is usually deposited on the line pattern for both att.PSM and
alternating PSM to control the line width. Because of no shading material for CPL, the required resist critical dimension
(CD) has to be obtained by using phase only and it is difficult to control the resist CD through pitch. As expected, CPL
needs smaller dose than att.PSM to make the desired 45 nm CD with 0.94 NA. Our simulation results showed that 10 nm
negative bias is optimum for CPL mask. We demonstrated that CPL mask and att.PSM technology can be used to make
45 nm node by the negative space bias.
Improvement of the common DoF across field for hole-structure process layers
Show abstract
It is well-known that the available depth of focus (DoF) tend to decrease for each advancing technology node.
Moreover the leveling control on wafer topography has become a challenge to affect the focus control on exposure tool
capability, especially for the critical hole-structure layer of the back end of line (BEoL). In this study, we used the via
layer from the real products as an example of optimizing the exposure tool's leveling system to reduce process-related
influences to improve the intra-field focus control range. First, the focus-exposure matrices (FEMs) were applied to a
wafer in different leveling modes. Then, patterns' critical dimension (CD) in different locations within the same field
were measured to produce the Bossung curves required to determine the best focus. The same steps were repeated on a
bare wafer to illustrate how the process reduced the common depth of focus range. We also introduced the non-optical
leveling sensor, which measured the wafer by the use of physical methods. Since it does not interact with the film stack
or the pattern density, the measurement accuracy will be insensitive to process variation. Therefore, it can be used to
compensate the optically induced errors from the optical leveling system and to expand the useful depth of focus for
improving CD uniformity. Finally, we briefly summarize the improvement ratio achieved of the common DoF using
these optical and non-optical leveling systems with different leveling modes.
Customized illumination shapes for 193nm immersion lithography
Show abstract
In this paper, a study on customized illumination shape configurations as resolution enhancement for 45nm technology
node will be presented. Several new source shape configurations will be explored through simulation based on 193nm
immersion lithography on 6% Attenuated Phase Shift Mask. Forbidden pitch effect is commonly encountered in the
application of off axis illumination (OAI). The illumination settings are often optimized to allow maximum process
window for a pitch. This is done by creating symmetrical distribution of diffraction order on the pupil plane. However, at
other pitch, the distribution of diffraction order on the pupil plane results in severe degradation in image contrast and
results in significant critical dimension (CD) fluctuation. The problematic pitch is often known as forbidden pitch. It has
to be avoided in the design and thus limited the pitch range to be imaged for particular illumination. An approach to
modify off axis illumination to minimize the effect of forbidden pitch is explored in this study. The new customized
shape for one dimensional line and space pattern is modified from current off axis illumination. Simulation study is done
to evaluate the performance some customized shapes. The extent of CD fluctuation and CD through pitch uniformity is
analyzed to determine the performance enhancement of the new illumination shapes. From simulation result, the
proposed modification have significantly improved the through pitch performance and minimized the effect of forbidden
pitch.
Binary and attenuated PSM mask evaluation for sub 50nm device development perspective
Show abstract
As the semiconductor industry continues progressing toward increasingly complex and
unforgiving processes of device shrinkage and shorter duration of device development, many
industry participants from photo-lithography are taking interest in material and structure of the
photolithography mask. Due to shorter wavelength of the source laser and device technology
ranging around the order of magnitude for the source laser wavelength (ArF), the difference in mask
material and structure shows greater performance difference then larger technology node. Especially
around 50nm and beyond, many industry followers are reporting better performance from different
types of mask then previously used.
In this study, we will analyze the effect of the photo lithography mask material for sub
50nm device, in development perspective. Two major types of mask will be evaluated on the scale
of device development. Effects such as Mask Error Effect Factor (MEEF), Depth of Focus (DOF),
Exposure Latitude (EL) and Critical Dimension Uniformity (CDU) will be analyzed for both binary
and attenuated phase shifted mask under different process condition. Also, we will evaluate the
comparison result for application on development of sub 45nm device.
Highly reliable detection and correction of pinched areas for high transmission phase shift mask
Show abstract
HTPSM (High-Transmission Phase Shift Mask) is one of the most promising mask technologies for photolithography
resolution enhancement. However, it s well known that the use of HTPSM frequently results in unwanted patterns due to
inevitable pinching effects, particularly in spacious areas. Although pinching effect can be effectively suppressed by the
application of additional Cr patterns at the problematic locations, it is a critical challenge to systematically detect and
automatically correct the complicated patterns in most of realistic cases.
We demonstrated remarkable photolithography process window improvement by the use of HTPSM (A type and
above) with the focus on the development of a systematic methodology for automatic detection and correction of abnormal
patterns due to optical pinching effect. Regular optical rules check (ORC) with specific modifications was employed to
precisely locate the potential pinched areas, whereas enhanced design rules check (DRC) was applied subsequently to
generate the required additional Cr patterns for final mask fabrication. A variety of photolithography variables, such as
wavelength and numerical aperture (NA) were extensively investigated against optical pinching effect to confirm the
feasibility and accuracy of the proposed detection/correction methodology for HTPSM application.
Evaluation of inverse lithography technology for 55nm-node memory device
Show abstract
Model based OPC has been generally used to correct proximity effects down to ~50 nm critical dimensions at
k1 values around 0.3. As design rules shrink and k1 drops below 0.3, however; it is very hard to obtain enough process
window and acceptable MEEF (Mask Error Enhancement Factor) with conventional model based OPC. Recently, ILT
(Inverse Lithography Technology) has been introduced and has demonstrated wider process windows than conventional
OPC. The ILT developed by Luminescent uses level-set methods to find the optimal photo mask layout, which
maximizes the process window subject to mask manufacturing constraints.
We have evaluated performance of ILT for critical dimensions of 55nm, printed under conditions
corresponding to k1 ~ 0.28. Results indicated a larger process window and better pattern fidelity than obtained with
other methods. In this paper, we present the optimization procedures, model calibration and evaluation results for 55 nm
metal and contact layers and discuss the possibilities and the limitations of this new technology.
Extension of low k1 lithography processes with KrF for 90nm technology node
Show abstract
We discussed to KrF process extension for 90 nm technology node. The continuous shrinkage of critical dimensions on
sub 130 nm devices becomes a key point to improve process margin with pattern resolution problem for lithography.
Recently, according to development demand of high density and high integration device, it is tendency that the shrink
rate of design rule is gradually accelerated. It is difficult to develop with image contrast problem around k1=0.25 which
is a theoretical process limit region. We need to technology development which is available to having resolution for sub
90nm line and space by using KrF lithography not by using ArF lithography.
In generally, KrF have not been used in nano-process such as 90nm technology. In this study, however, we can apply
the KrF in 90nm technology by means of minimizing the error range in the nano-process, optimizing the process, and
extending the process margin. This Application of KrF in 90nm technology results in elimination of additional
investment for development of 90nm technology.
Finally, we will show which simulation and experimental results such as normalized image log slope, pupil plane,
image of focus variation, process window, top view image, photo resist and etch profile, and pitch linearity.
60nm half pitch contact layer printing: exploring the limits at 1.35NA lithography
Show abstract
The ever increasing NA to meet the stringent requirements on pitch and litho target does not come without a price. In
particular for the printing of contact layers, the toll is taken in terms of decreased process latitudes and CD uniformity.
Depending on the specific contact layer design, it has become increasingly important to choose the most adequate
resolution enhancement technique. At the ultimate NA of 1.35, depth of focus through pitch has become a key factor,
and values in the order of 100-120nm are the painful truth imposed by physics. In this paper, the attention goes to
through-pitch contact imaging, with the attempt to achieve half pitches around 60nm. Thereby, the main focus lies on the
relation between source shape and minimum achievable k1. In addition, the pro's and con's of two options for throughpitch
process latitude enhancement are considered. These options are firstly the effect of assist feature placement in
combination with off-axis illumination, and secondly the application of the Focus Drilling technique. Finally, the
different contributions to contact hole CD non-uniformity are addressed.
Combined mask and illumination scheme optimization for robust contact patterning on 45nm technology node flash memory devices
Show abstract
Immersion Lithography is the most important technique for extending optical lithography's capabilities and meeting the
requirements of Semiconductor Roadmap. The introduction of immersion tools has recently allowed the development of
45nm technology node in single exposure. Nevertheless the usage of hyper-high NA scanners (NA > 1), some levels still
remain very critical to be imaged with sufficient process performances. For memory devices, contact mask is for sure the
most challenging layer.
Aim of this paper is to present the lithographic assessment of 193nm contact holes process, with k1 value of ~0.30 using
NA 1.20 immersion lithography (minimum pitch is 100nm). Different issues will be reported, related to mask choices
(Binary or Attenuated Phase Shift) and illuminator configurations.
First phase of the work will be dedicated to a preliminary experimental screening on a simple test case in order to reduce
the variables in the following optimization sections. Based on this analysis we will discard X-Y symmetrical illuminators
(Annular, C-Quad) due to poor contrast. Second phase will be dedicated to a full simulation assessment. Different
illuminators will be compared, with both mask type and several mask biases. From this study, we will identify some
general trends of lithography performances that can be used for the fine tuning of the RET settings. The last phase of the
work will be dedicated to find the sensitivity trends for one of the analyzed illuminators. In particular we study the effect
of Numerical Aperture, mask bias in both X and Y direction and poles sigma ring-width and centre.
32 nm logic patterning options with immersion lithography
Show abstract
The semiconductor industry faces a lithographic scaling limit as the industry completes the transition to 1.35 NA
immersion lithography. Both high-index immersion lithography and EUV lithography are facing technical
challenges and commercial timing issues. Consequently, the industry has focused on enabling double patterning
technology (DPT) as a means to circumvent the limitations of Rayleigh scaling. Here, the IBM development
alliance demonstrate a series of double patterning solutions that enable scaling of logic constructs by decoupling
the pattern spatially through mask design or temporally through innovative processes. These techniques have been
successfully employed for early 32nm node development using 45nm generation tooling. Four different double
patterning techniques were implemented. The first process illustrates local RET optimization through the use of a
split reticle design. In this approach, a layout is decomposed into a series of regions with similar imaging
properties and the illumination conditions for each are independently optimized. These regions are then printed
separately into the same resist film in a multiple exposure process. The result is a singly developed pattern that
could not be printed with a single illumination-mask combination. The second approach addresses 2D imaging
with particular focus on both line-end dimension and linewidth control [1]. A double exposure-double etch (DE2)
approach is used in conjunction with a pitch-filling sacrificial feature strategy. The third double exposure process,
optimized for via patterns also utilizes DE2. In this method, a design is split between two separate masks such that
the minimum pitch between any two vias is larger than the minimum metal pitch. This allows for final structures
with vias at pitches beyond the capability of a single exposure. In the fourth method,, dark field double dipole
lithography (DDL) has been successfully applied to BEOL metal structures and has been shown to be overlay
tolerant [6]. Collectively, the double patterning solutions developed for early learning activities at 32nm can be
extended to 22nm applications.
Poster Session: OPC and Mask Technology
Consideration of VT5 etch-based OPC modeling
Show abstract
Including etch-based empirical data during OPC model calibration is a desired yet controversial decision for OPC
modeling, especially for process with a large litho to etch biasing. While many OPC software tools are capable of
providing this functionality nowadays; yet few were implemented in manufacturing due to various risks considerations
such as compromises in resist and optical effects prediction, etch model accuracy or even runtime concern. Conventional
method of applying rule-based alongside resist model is popular but requires a lot of lengthy code generation to provide
a leaner OPC input. This work discusses risk factors and their considerations, together with introduction of techniques
used within Mentor Calibre VT5 etch-based modeling at sub 90nm technology node. Various strategies are discussed
with the aim of better handling of large etch bias offset without adding complexity into final OPC package. Finally,
results were presented to assess the advantages and limitations of the final method chosen.
Optimized OPC approach for process window improvement
Show abstract
Within the past several years, IC design and manufacture technology node transits rapidly from 0.13um to 65nm and 45nm. Whatever the technology node is, the same goal that both the designer and the manufacturer put most of their effort on is how to improve the chip yield as high as possible. A bunch of evidences have shown that the final yield is extremely related to the pattern transfer from design to wafer. But with the critical dimension shrinks, the largest challenge that the whole industry meets is how to keep high fidelity while transferring the patterns. Since the process window is now very limited even with the assistance of kinds of resolution enhancement technology, a tiny process deviation may cause large critical dimension variation, which will result in significant device character change. Micro-lithography combined with Optical proximity correct is supposed to be the most critical stage in pattern transfer stage. But conventional OPC always use nominal model, which will not take random process variation into account during applying OPC. This work will demonstrate our experiment in OPC with process window model, which is then proved to have obvious improvement in pattern fidelity.
The comparison of OPC performance and run time for dense versus sparse solutions
Show abstract
The lithographic processes and resolution enhancement techniques (RET) needed to achieve pattern fidelity are
becoming more complicated as the required critical dimensions (CDs) shrink. For technology nodes with smaller
devices and tolerances, more complex models and proximity corrections are needed and these significantly increase
the computational requirements. New simulation techniques are required to address these computational challenges.
The new simulation technique we focus on in this work is dense optical proximity correction (OPC). Sparse OPC
tools typically require a laborious, manual and time consuming OPC optimization approach. In contrast, dense OPC
uses pixel-based simulation that does not need as much manual setup. Dense OPC was introduced because sparse
simulation methodology causes run times to explode as the pattern density increases, since the number of simulation
sites in a given optical radius increases.
In this work, we completed a comparison of the OPC modeling performance and run time for the dense and the
sparse solutions. The analysis found the computational run time to be highly design dependant. The result should
lead to the improvement of the quality and performance of the OPC solution and shed light on the pros and cons of
using dense versus sparse solution. This will help OPC engineers to decide which solution to apply to their
particular situation.
Advanced mask process modeling for 45-nm and 32-nm nodes
Show abstract
As tolerance requirements for the lithography process continue to shrink with each new technology node, the
contributions of all process sequence steps to the critical dimension error budgets are being closely examined, including
wafer exposure, resist processing, pattern etch, as well as the photomask process employed during the wafer exposure.
Along with efforts to improve the mask manufacturing processes, the elimination of residual mask errors via pattern
correction has gained renewed attention. The portfolio of correction tools for mask process effects is derived from well
established techniques commonly used in optical proximity correction and in electron beam proximity effect
compensation. The process component that is not well captured in the correction methods deployed in mask
manufacturing today is etch. A mask process model to describe the process behavior and to capture the physical effects
leading to deviation of the critical dimension from the target value represents the key component of model-based
correction and verification. This paper presents the flow for generating mask process models that describe both shortrange
and long-range mask process effects, including proximity loading effects from etching, pattern density loading
effects, and across-mask process non-uniformity. The flow is illustrated with measurement data from real test masks.
Application of models for both mask process correction and verification is discussed.
An efficient and robust mask model for lithography simulation
Show abstract
We formulate the mask modeling as a parametric model order reduction problem. We then apply a robust reduction
technique to generate the compact mask model. Since this model is based on first principle, it naturally includes diffraction,
polarization and couplings, important effects that are poorly handled by the modified thin-mask model (MTMM). The
model generation involves only a few sampling solves of the governing equation, much fewer than that needed to generate
MTMM. Though the model evaluation takes marginally more CPU time than MTMM, the accuracy and the robustness of
the new model are based on much more rigorous theoretical foundation.
Reticle CD error calibrated OPC model generation
Show abstract
Resolution enhancement technologies (RET), such as optical proximity correction (OPC) help us develop sub-
100nm technology node by using photolithography equipments and materials for 130nm photolithographic process.
Because the resolution of scanner and materials has arrived almost at their limit, small patterns below resolution limit are
more sensitively affected by very small tolerance of various factors which were not considered by major process
parameters such like lens flare, reticle haze, reticle critical dimensional (CD) errors, etc. As patterning small ones under
resolution limit directly means large MEEF (mask error enhancement factor) in photo process, reticle CD errors are
actually magnified on wafer. Therefore, reticle CD errors should be tightly controlled when we try to define small
patterns under resolution limit.
As the feature size shrinks down, the importance of OPC model accuracy grows up for the purpose of ensuring
high pattern fidelity. In conventional process of OPC model generation, we don't concern how mask database CDs are
exactly matched with real reticle CDs, since the specification of reticle CD is enough tight to ignore CD variation on the
reticle such as 1-dimensional CD difference, linearity CD uniformity. But in the process with large MEEF, OPC model
with incorrect CD information of reticle has a bad influence to prediction pattern fidelity.
In this paper, we describe the effect of reticle CD errors on the OPC model accuracy. To quantify that effect, we
compared two cases of OPC model generation. One is making OPC model by using mask database CDs themselves, the
other is by using mask real CDs in 110nm node for poly and metal 1 (damascene) layers. As a consequence of the test,
we can achieve the accuracy OPC model calibrated with reticle CD errors which better predicts wafer CDs and 2-
dimensional images than the model, calibrated by original database CDs.
Modeling of focus blur in the context of optical proximity correction
Show abstract
The concept of focus blur encompasses the effect of laser bandwidth longitudinal
chromatic aberration and scanner stage vertical vibration. The finite bandwidth of
excimer laser source causes a corresponding finite distribution of focal planes in a range
of 100nm or larger for the optical lithography system. Similarly, scanner vertical stage
vibration puts the wafer in a finite distribution of focal planes. Both chromatic aberration
and vertical stage vibration could introduce significant CD errors, hence can no longer be
ignored in current lithography processes development and OPC development that require
CD control within a few nanometers. We developed several methodologies to model the
laser chromatic aberration and vertical stage vibration in OPC (Optical Proximity
Correction) modeling tool. Extensive simulations were done to calculate chromatic
aberration and vertical stage vibration focus blur's impact on lithography patterning for a
variety of test structures. Chromatic aberration and vertical stage vibration focus blur
effect was further included as an regression term in experimental OPC model calibration
to capture its impact on litho patterning, and significant benefit to OPC model calibration
was observed.
Full chip compensation for local-flare-induced CD error using OPC/DRC method
Show abstract
Flare has become a significant problem for low K1 lithography process.[1] It is generally divided into three parts:
long-, local-, short-range. Long-range flare is scattering over a scale of tens of microns, come from reflections within the
projection lens. Short-range is scattering over a scale of about 1 micron or less, come from lens aberrations. And localrange
flare is scattering over about 1 to 10 microns, comes from inhomogenieties within glass and local pattern density.
Especially, local-range flare causes the printed width to vary or degrade printing accuracy. Normally, the local-range
flare effect is increase by local pattern density. Therefore the local flare effect can be reduced if the effect of local pattern
density within die is compensated effectively.
In this paper, we discussed full chip compensation for local flare effect using OPC/DRC method. First of all, we
investigated relationship between local flare and pattern density using test pattern and extracted OPC model according
to pattern density and also analyzed within chip pattern density distribution using DRC. We separated original layout to
OPC target layout according to local pattern density, applied different OPC model to each separated layout. We will
show within chip CD variation was improved after local flare effects reduction.
Development of layout split algorithms and printability evaluation for double patterning technology
Show abstract
When using the most advanced water-based immersion scanner at the 32nm node half-pitch, the image resolution will
be below the k1 limit of 0.25. If EUV technology is not ready for mass production, double patterning technology
(DPT) is one of the solutions to bridge the gap between wet ArF and EUV platforms. DPT technology implies a
patterning process with two photolithography/etching steps. As a result, the critical pitch is reduced by a factor of 2,
which means the k1 value could increase by a factor of 2. Due to the superimposition of patterns printed by two
separate patterning steps, the overlay capability, in addition to image capability, contributes to critical dimension
uniformity (CDU). The wafer throughput as well as cost is a concern because of the increased number of process
steps. Therefore, the performance of imaging, overlay, and throughput of a scanner must be improved in order to
implement DPT cost effectively. In addition, DPT requires an innovative software to evenly split the patterns into two
layers for the full chip. Although current electronic design automation (EDA) tools can split the pattern through
abundant geometry-manipulation functions, these functions, however, are insufficient. A rigorous pattern split requires
more DPT-specific functions such as tagging/grouping critical features with two colors (and hence two layers),
controlling the coloring sequence, correcting the printing error on stitching boundaries, dealing with color conflicts,
increasing the coloring accuracy, considering full-chip possibility, etc. Therefore, in this paper we cover these issues
by demonstrating a newly developed DPT pattern-split algorithm using a rule-based method. This method has one
strong advantage of achieving very fast processing speed, so a full-chip DPT pattern split is practical. After the pattern
split, all of the color conflicts are highlighted. Some of the color conflicts can be resolved by aggressive model-based
methods, while the un-resolvable conflicts, known as native conflicts, require a change in the design to achieve a DPTfriendly
design. A model-based stitching boundary correction is then used after the color conflicts are corrected.
Finally the OPC treatment is implemented on both split layouts. The OPC challenges are highlighted by examining the
printed image from both exposures. The key concepts described above with additional full chip requirements have
been successfully implemented onto Brion's TachyoTM system. The efficiency and accuracy of the DPT pattern split
method were evaluated on a full-chip layout. The results show that the algorithm proposed in this paper is a viable
solution for the DPT pattern split.
Optical proximity correction with principal component regression
Show abstract
An important step in today's Integrated Circuit (IC) manufacturing is optical proximity correction (OPC). In
model based OPC, masks are systematically modified to compensate for the non-ideal optical and process effects
of optical lithography system. The polygons in the layout are fragmented, and simulations are performed to
determine the image intensity pattern on the wafer. Then the mask is perturbed by moving the fragments to
match the desired wafer pattern. This iterative process continues until the pattern on the wafer matches the
desired one. Although OPC increases the fidelity of pattern transfer to the wafer, it is quite CPU intensive; OPC
for modern IC designs can take days to complete on computer clusters with thousands of CPU. In this paper,
techniques from statistical machine learning are used to predict the fragment movements. The goal is to reduce
the number of iterations required in model based OPC by using a fast and efficient solution as the initial guess to
model based OPC. To determine the best model, we train and evaluate several principal component regression
models based on prediction error. Experimental results show that fragment movement predictions via regression
model significantly decrease the number of iterations required in model based OPC.
OPC optimization for double dipole lithography and its application on 45nm node with dry exposure
Show abstract
Various resolution enhancement techniques have been proposed in order to enable optical lithography
at low k1 imaging, e.g. alt-PSM (phase shift mask), chromeless phase lithography (CPL), double
exposure technique (DET) and double dipole lithography (DDL). In spite of its low throughput in
production, DDL technique is a very attractive solution for low k1 process because of the relatively low
cost of binary or attenuated phase shift masks, which can be combined with strong dipole illuminations
and flexible SRAF rule to enhance the process window. Another attraction of DDL is that dry scanner
still can be used for 45nm node instead of expensive immersion lithography process.
In this paper, two aspects for DDL application have been focused on. The first one is OPC optimization
method for DDL, which includes SRAF optimization, mask decomposition and pixel-based OPC. The
whole flow is optimized specifically for DDL to achieve satisfactory pattern results on wafer. The
second is the overlay issue. Since two DDL masks are exposed in turn, the overlay variation between
two masks becomes dominant factor deteriorating pattern quality. The effect of overlay tolerance is also
studied through process window simulation.
DDL has been demonstrated to be capable of 45nm node logic with dry scanner. The pattern fidelity and
process window of 45nm node SRAM & Random Logic are evaluated for active/gate layer and dark
field metal layer.
Novel method for optimizing lithography exposure conditions using full-chip post-OPC simulation
Show abstract
At 65 nm and below, full-chip verification of OPC is done for nominal dose and focus, as well as for
process corners representing a two-to-three sigma deviation from the manufacturing setpoints. Such an
approach interrogates the intersection of design layout with process variation to elucidate specific locations
which will tend to be yield-limiting in manufacturing. With vanishingly small margins between allowable
process windows and real in-fab variability, it is of utmost importance to optimize the critical exposure
parameters such as projection optic numerical aperture, illumination source mode and sigma, and source
polarization. The traditional approach to optimizing these exposure conditions has involved selecting
representative feature test patterns (such as 1D lines at multiple pitches, or memory cells), placing
simulation cutlines across selected locations, establishing allowable CD tolerances, and calculating
overlapping process windows for all cutlines of interest. Such approaches are to first order effective in
coarse tuning exposure conditions, but underutilize the rich information content which is available from
today's rapid large-area post-OPC simulation engines. We report here on the use of full-chip post-OPC
simulation and error checking in conjunction with illumination optimization tooling to provide a more
thorough and versatile statistical analysis capability. It is shown that the new method proposed here results
in a more robust process window than that which would be obtained by the conditions selected using the
traditional optimization method.
Optical proximity correction for elongated contact-hole printing
Show abstract
Optical proximity correction (OPC) of contact-hole printing is challenging since its two dimensional shapes requires
through understanding of lithographic processes compared to one dimensional line and space pattering. Moreover,
recently, it is common to use "elongated contact holes" with large contact area, rather than simple circular ones, for small
electrical resistance. These elongated contact holes make it even more difficult to generate a good OPC model than the
circular ones because the elongated contact-hole patterning causes the asymmetric process effects. For example, impacts
of mask CD error, resist diffusion and resist development are different depending on the orientation of the elongated
contact holes. This paper presents how the OPC model for the elongated contact-hole can be improved as the mask CD
error compensation, accurate resist diffusion model and a new Variable Threshold Model (VTM) are applied for the
asymmetric process effects.
Study of the mask topography effect on the OPC modeling of hole patterns
Show abstract
Recently, there have been many studies on the mask topography effect on patterning. Most of existing papers report
generally focused on the difference of the aerial image between the thin mask approximation and the rigorous
topographic mask models. In this paper, the mask topography effect was analyzed from an OPC modeling perspective.
We compared the accuracy of two types of the virtual OPC model of contact patterns that one model used the virtual test
patterns generated by the lithography simulator based on the thin mask approximation model and the virtual test patterns
of another model were made by the rigorous topographic mask simulation based on FDTD (Finite Difference Time
Domain) method. All conditions of lithography simulations and OPC modeling between two models were same except
the mask topography parameters in generating virtual test patterns. Differences in model accuracy and convergence
values of regression parameters of each models indicated that current OPC modeling tool based on the thin mask
approximated optical simulation did not sufficiently cover the mask topography effect, and 3D mask effect should be
considered more carefully.
Evaluation of OPC test patterns using parameter sensitivity
Show abstract
Test pattern data set filtering based on the concept of parameter sensitivity is proposed to reduce OPC time-to-model
requirements. The concept of parameter sensitivity-based filtering is discussed briefly, followed by a methodology to
apply the filtering to test pattern sets prior to data measurement along with a number of potential data filtering
algorithms. The proposed methodology is then applied to an experimental data set targeted for a 32nm logic process.
Qualitative observations are made on the initial data filtering, followed by quantitative metrics based on best-fit models
for each of the data filtering algorithms. Results demonstrate that a comparable model is achievable using the proposed
data filtering methods and one of the filtering algorithms.
Pellicle effect on OPC modeling
Show abstract
As the patterning of IC manufacturing shrinks to the 32-nm node and beyond, high-NA and immersion lithography are
required for pushing resolution to its physical limit. To achieve good OPC performance, various physical effects such as
polarization, mask topography, and mask pellicle have to be considered to improve the model accuracy.
The attenuation and the phase variation of TE and TM wave components induced by the pellicle would impact optical
qualities in terms of resolution, distortion, defocus shift, and high-order aberrations. In this paper, the OPC model
considering pellicle effects is investigated with Jones pupil. The CD variation induced by the pellicle effect can be
predicted accurately. Therefore, the improvement on model accuracy for 32-nm node is demonstrated.
OPC model calibration considerations for data variance
Show abstract
OPC models have been improving their accuracy over the years by modeling more error sources in the
lithographic systems, but model calibration techniques are improving at a slower pace. One area of
modeling calibration that has garnered little interest is the statistical variance of the calibration data
set. OPC models are very susceptible to parameter divergence with statistical variance, but modest caution
is given to the data variance once the calibration sequence has started. Not only should the calibration data
be a good representation of the design intent, but measure redundancy is required to take into consideration
the process and metrology variance. Considering it takes five to nine redundant measurements to generate
a good statistical distribution for averaging and it takes tens of thousands of measurements to mimic the
design intent, the data volume requirements become overwhelming. Typically, the data redundancy is
reduced due to this data explosion, so some level of variance will creep into the model-tuning process.
This is a feasibility study for treatment of data variance during model calibration. This approach was
developed to improve the model fitness for primary out-of-specification features present in the calibration
test pattern by performing small manipulations of the measured data combined with data weighting during
the model calibration process. This data manipulation is executed in image-parameter groups (Imin, Imax,
slope and curvature) to control model convergence. These critical-CD perturbations are typically fractions
of nanometers, which is consistent with the residual variance of the statically valid data set. With this datamanipulation
approach the critical features are pulled into specification without diverging other feature
types.
This paper will detail this model calibration technique and the use of imaging parameters and weights to
converge the model for key feature types. It will also demonstrate its effectiveness on realistic
applications.
Pattern centric OPC flow: a special RET flow with fast turn-around-time
Show abstract
Low K1 photolithography process increases the complexity of RET applications in IC
designs. As technology node shrinks, pattern density is much denser along with much
smaller geometry dimensions. Model-based OPC (Optical Proximity Correction) and
post-OPC verification require more complex models and through process window
compensated approaches, which significantly increase computational burden. Both
lithographical challenges and computational complexity associated with 45nm process
and below create a need for advanced capabilities on commercial OPC tools. To
answer those challenges, hardware-accelerated OPC solution made a debut to solve
runtime bottleneck issues, but they came in with very expensive price tags. As today,
there are no explorations on the linkage between design styles and layout pattern OPC
reusability.
This paper introduces a new OPC flow with pattern-centric approach to leverage OPC
knowledge of repeated design cells and patterns to achieve fast full chip OPC
convergence, shorter cycle time, better OPC quality, and eventually lead to high
manufacturing yields. In this paper, the main concepts of pattern-based OPC flow are
demonstrated in 65nm customer memory designs. Pattern-based OPC is a natural
extension of Anchor's pattern-centric approaches in DFM (Design for Manufacturing)
domain.
Extreme mask corrections: technology and benefits
Show abstract
We establish criteria to recognize extreme OPC corrections and discuss their difference from the traditional corrections.
Then we present new proximity correction methods for rigorous bi- and tri- tone mask optimization that cast problem as
a constraint minimization over the space of piecewise constant or continuous functions. The primary optimization
objective is stated as a contour integral over the target. The constraints on image amplitude form convex functionals for
dark areas and non-convex functionals for bright areas. A Lagrangian of this constrained problem is minimized. This
delivers extreme, aggressive mask corrections, which are not confined by the fragmentation schema or the orientation of
its sites. We analyze performance of these corrections under challenging process conditions and evaluate fidelity
benefits.
Variable loading kernels for OPC modeling
Show abstract
The low k1-factor challenge in current photolithography has made OPC (Optical Proximity Correction) indispensable for critical patterning layers, and more efforts are needed in the development and calibration of OPC model. One of the key factors that affect the accuracy of wafer result is the accuracy of OPC model, and usually, only a few nanometers' fitting residual of OPC model is tolerable. So, several methods have been reported for improving the accuracy of OPC modeling, but the model fitting becomes more complex as the increase of fitting parameters accordingly.
In this paper, the variable loading kernel to manipulate the behavior of OPC modeling was reported. The variable load kernel can be modified by space domain, and it also can be the combination of many load kernels, such as Kload= a1*Kload1 + a2*Kload2 + ...... + an*Kloadn. By combining of different variable load kernels, the resultant load kernel can be more flexible to manage the model behavior in different line widths and pitches. In the example of OPC fitting residuals of linearity patterns, it is obvious that the different models with different loading kernels yielded different residuals. The use of variable loading kernel achieves the satisfied small residuals for both small and large patterns simultaneously. Accordingly, easier OPC modeling with smaller fitting residual is anticipated by variable load kernel method.
Impact of medium and long range effects on poly gate patterning
Show abstract
CD control specifications for poly gate patterning are becoming tighter and tighter: latest revisions of International
Technology Roadmap for Semiconductors require a CD control in the range of 2.2nm (3σ) for the 65nm technology
node. In this scenario model-based Optical Proximity Correction methodologies, traditionally developed to address
optical and resist development effects, had to face the challenge to correct post-resist processing steps with the aim to
guarantee a final effective CD control within expected specifications. Complex 1D rule-based corrections, applied in the
past, are no more adequate to capture complex 2D effects becoming relevant starting from 90nm node; only a more
comprehensive 2D model-based approach can correctly predict, and so compensate, complex physical and chemical etch
phenomena inducing CD variations. In this paper we experimentally study the impact of medium and long range etch
effects on poly gate patterning, trying to identify their nature and impact on intra-die CD variations. Different innovative
model-based approaches for lithography and etch effects compensation are evaluated and compared on Flash memory
circuitry (90, 65 and 45 nm node) with the aim to reduce intra-die CD dispersion component. Finally the impact of local
and global pattern density on etch behavior is studied in relation to different dummy placement strategies.
Design of automatic controllers for model-based OPC with optimal resist threshold determination for improving correction convergence
Show abstract
Model-based Optical Proximity Correction (MBOPC) has become one of the most important resolution enhancement
technologies (RETs), which can effectively improve the image fidelity and process robustness. MBOPC is performed by
iteratively shifting the polygon edges of mask patterns until convergence requirements are achieved. In this paper, we
specifically discuss the design of feedback controllers to improve MBOPC convergence. Effective controller design rules
are derived from the OPC results of several circuit layouts. Meanwhile, resist models also significantly affect MBOPC
convergence. Two kinds of resist model have been proposed for MBOPC such as constant threshold resist model (CTRM)
and variable threshold resist model (VTRM). We propose a novel CTRM, called pattern-based optimal threshold
determination (PBOTD). By normalized mean square error (NMSE) formulation, appropriate threshold values with
minimum NMSE can be determined to improve image fidelity, and effectively decrease iterations required. The
effectiveness of applying both optimized controller and PBOTD is demonstrated on a 90-nm SRAM cell.
OPC modeling setup with considering flare effect
Show abstract
Flare is unwanted light arriving at the wafer and light causing negative impact on pattern formation. It is caused
by scattered light from lens surfaces, problem on lens design, or problem on lens manufacture. The impact of flare varies
printed line widths or drops CD uniformity accuracy in full chip. And, It is an added incoherent background intensity that
will degrade OPC(Optical Proximity Correction) accuracy[1].
In this paper, we discussed CD variation, MEEF (Mask Error Enhancement Factor) and OPC accuracy by the
flare effects. Flare is bound up with local pattern density. Local pattern density influences background intensity by flare
or stray light. So we studied CD variation, MEEF, OPC modeling data with local pattern density by several experiment.
Also, in this study, we will discuss test pattern drawing for OPC modeling data, analyze CD difference between OPC test
pattern with considering flare effect and test pattern with regardless flare effect and MEEF value by flare effect. MEEF is
main factor that influences lithography process margin. This paper will show test pattern optimization in OPC modeling.
Fitness and runtime correlation of compact model complexity
Show abstract
The development of efficient resist models for optical and process proximity correction (OPC) is a problem
of particular importance in microlithography. A resist model is considered efficient if it is fast and accurate
and properly accounts for the transfer of latent image patterns into resist shapes. Here we study the
runtime-accuracy tradeoff of the Compact Model 1 (CM1) resist model. The model is represented as a
linear combination of the aerial image, orthogonal basis functions, and other terms designed to mimic
various effects such as acid and base diffusion, slope, maximum and minimum local intensity, etc. Clearly,
the greater the number of terms involved the more flexible and accurate the model becomes. On the other
hand, adding too many terms to the model substantially increases the OPC runtime and may lead to
overfitting. Our goal is to find model forms that are optimal with respect to both runtime and accuracy.
This is achieved using a consecutive descent method for multi-objective optimization that seeks so-called
Pareto optimal solutions. We found that model forms which include the diffused acid term and orthogonal
basis functions almost always represent a reasonable compromise between fitness and performance.
Poster Session: Process
AltPSM contact hole application at DRAM 4xnm nodes with dry 193nm lithography
Show abstract
To avoid expensive immersion lithography and to further use existing dry tools for critical contact layer lithography at
4Xnm DRAM nodes the application of altPSM is investigated and compared to attPSM. Simulations and experiments
with several test masks showed that by use of altPSM with suitable 0°/180° coloring and assist placement 30nm smaller
contacts can be resolved through pitch with sufficient process windows (PW). This holds for arrays of contacts with
variable lengths through short and long side pitches. A further benefit is the lower mask error enhancement factor
(MEEF). Nevertheless 3D mask errors (ME) consume benefits in the PW and the assist placement and coloring of the
main features (MF) put some constraints on the chip design. An altPSM compatible 4Xnm full-chip layout was realized
without loss of chip area. Mask making showed very convincing results with respect to CDU, etch depth uniformity and
defectiveness. The printed intra-field CD uniformity was comparable to attPSM despite the smaller target CDs. Room for
improvement is identified in OPC accuracy and in automatic assist placement and sizing.
An approach for nanometer trench and hole formation
Show abstract
Patterning trench-hole type of structures with CD in nanometer dimension is very challenging in optical lithography due
to limited depth of focus (DOF) and exposure latitude (EL). We have proposed an integration process to convert sub-
100nm line/post type of structure to trench/hole type of structure. The proposed method as well as its variations may
have various potential applications, such as formation of plated perpendicular magnetic writer pole, bottom-up nanointerconnect,
nano-wires and other out-of-plane nano-structures. We have shown the feasibility for formation of nanotrenches
in various sub-100nm dimensions. Magnetic writer pole with 50nm critical dimensions (CD) and wellcontrolled
sidewalls was demonstrated by using this approach. The minimum CD of the starting isolated line/post
feature determines the minimum CD of the trench/hole structure.
Multi-patterning overlay control
Show abstract
The extension of optical lithography to 32nm and beyond is dependent on double-patterning (DP) at critical levels. DP integration strategies result in added degrees of freedom for overlay variation. In particular, overlay control requires assessment of error among various mask/level combinations. The Blossom overlay metrology approach minimizes the size of the overlay marks associated with each mask/level while maximizing the density of marks within the overlay metrology tool's field of view (FOV). We examine Blossom enabled use cases in DP lithography control; specifically, within-field and multiple mask/level sampling.
Resist bias measured in Iso-focal structure
Show abstract
In modern photolithography as the feature sizes reduce, the simulation of manufacturing process calls on more and
more accurate grasp of various effects in the process. While the optical simulation is calculated precisely by both firstprinciple
simulators and optical proximity correction (OPC) model simulator, an accurate and computational inexpensive
resist model has yet to be developed. After the exposure, resist parameters change the resist part of the proximity
effects by either moving the "optical image" or responding differently to varying image qualities. By inspecting the
wafer data, one can only see the results after development, which is the mixture of optical and resist effects. To isolate
the effect contributed by resist, it is necessary to separate the optical component and resist component. In this paper, a
novel method is proposed to determine the resist bias from the iso-focal structure, the critical dimension (CD) of which
was measured under different defocus conditions. The results extracted from experiments indicate that a constant CD
bias can catch most of resist effect at the first order of approximation.
Reflection control in hyper-NA immersion lithography
Show abstract
The impact of bottom reflection on critical dimension (CD) processing window is intensively investigated with a
simulation using a full diffraction model (FDM) in which the effective reflectivity is calculated from standing wave
amplitude. Most importantly, the optical phase shift of the reflection is used as a design criterion and was found to be
the primary factor that affects the UV distribution, and, hence, has a strong impact on exposure latitude and depth of
focus. Foot exposure (FE) is introduced as a new metric to characterize the phase shift. Some single-layer and dual-layer
bottom anti-reflective coating (BARC) designs were implemented with an Exitech MS-193i immersion micro-stepper
(NA=1.3) for 45-nm dense lines at the Resist Test Center (RTC) at International SEMATECH, Albany, New
York. The experimental results show that FE is closely related to the CD processing window. In contrast to
conventional BARC usage, a small amount of substrate reflection with a controlled optical phase shift dramatically
improves CD processing window.
Resolution enhancement techniques in 65 nm node nested-hole patterning
Show abstract
In this paper, it is described in great details how we perform DOE (Design Of Experiments), simulations, narrowing the
candidates down, and optimizing them to achieve low COO and large process window RET in 65 nm node nested-hole
patterning. We are trying to find best condition of 65 nm tech node nested hole with dry ArF lithography process,
regarding porcess cost redcution and easy access to RETs.
32nm overlay improvement capabilities
Show abstract
The industry is facing a major challenge looking forward on the technology roadmap with respect to overlay control.
Immersion lithography has established itself as the POR for 45nm and for the next few nodes. As the gap closes between
scanner capability and device requirements new methodologies need to be taken into consideration. Double patterning
lithography is an approach that's being considered for 32 and below, but it creates very strict demands for overlay
performance. The fact that a single layer device will need to be patterned using two sequential single processes creates a
strong coupling between the 1st and 2nd exposure. The coupling effect during the double patterning process results in
extremely tight tolerances for overlay error and scanner capabilities.
The purpose of this paper is to explore a new modeling method to improve lithography performance for the 32nm node.
Not necessarily unique for double patterning, but as a general approach to improve overlay performance regardless of
which patterning process is implemented. We will achieve this by performing an in depth source of variance analysis of
current scanner performance and project the anticipated improvements from our new modeling approach. Since the new
modeling approach will involve 2nd and 3rd order corrections we will also provide and analysis that outlines current
metrology capabilities and sampling optimizations to further expand the opportunities of an efficient implementation of
such approach.
22nm half-pitch patterning by CVD spacer self alignment double patterning (SADP)
Show abstract
Self-aligned double patterning (SADP) is a patterning technique that uses CVD spacers formed adjacent to a core
(template) pattern that is defined by conventional lithography. After stripping the core (template) material, the
spacers serve as a hardmask with double the line density of the original lithographically defined template. This
integration scheme is an alternative to conventional double patterning for extending the half-pitch resolution
beyond the current lithography tool's half-pitch limit. Using a positive tone (spacer as mask) approach, we show
capability to create 22nm line and space arrays, on 300mm wafers, with full wafer critical dimension uniformity
(CDU) < 2nm (3 sigma) and line edge roughness (LER) < 2nm. These 22nm line and space results stem from
template lithography using 1.2NA 193nm water immersion lithography. In this paper, we also demonstrate lot to
lot manufacturability, the patterning of two substrate types (STI and silicon oxide trench), as well as demonstrate
the formation of gridded design rule (GDR) building blocks for circuit design.
Reflectivity-induced variation in implant layer lithography
Show abstract
Scaling of designs to the 45nm and future nodes presents challenges for block level lithography. Shrinking distances
between devices drive aggressive resist placement tolerances, challenging the ability to control critical dimension (CD).
In particular, the potential variation in shallow trench isolation oxide may result in variation of resist profile and CD,
thereby affecting edge placement accuracy. Potential sources of this include wafer-to-wafer or within-wafer STI trench
depth variations, and STI CMP variations that may be induced by active area pattern density fluctuations. Some other
potential sources of CD fluctuation include oxide sidewall variation, and implant level overlay or CD errors modulating
the proximity to the oxide sidewall. Depending on the actual variation of isolation oxide and the exposure latitude of the
resist, the CD variations simply from oxide variation may consume a large portion of the CD budget.
Several examples are given of variations in resist profile and CD arising from these substrate effects. The CD
uniformity of a test structure was shown to decrease dramatically with the addition of a BARC to the resist stack, most
likely due to the suppression of substrate reflectivity variations. Simulations performed using Panoramic Technologies
software demonstrated the potential sensitivity of the factors outlined above on CD and profile errors. A comparison of
simulated vs. experimental results is made for a case of intentional overlay error, showing the failure mode of the resist
profile as the mask edge passes from STI to the active area. The simulations using a full physical model provided with
the simulation software predict a resist foot forming over the active area, which was confirmed experimentally.
Investigation of mechanism of pattern deformation on TiN substrate and O2 plasma effect without BARC
Show abstract
The pattern deformation such as photoresist lifting after lithography due to not enough
photoresist adhesion to substrate is become critical issue when aspect ratio is much higher than
what photoresist adhesion can support. This aspect ratio is getting higher when our design rule
of device requests smaller feature size in lithography process. The BARC (Bottom Antireflective
Coating), which advanced lithography is using, is very good layer to improve adhesion of
photoresist since they are same kind of chemical. However, BARC needs extra etching process
before main etching which is step to remove substrate. Sometimes, this BARC etching step
generated defects which makes yield loss. Especially, lithography step for metallization with
aluminum likes without BARC process to be free from those defect. We think that adhesion of
photoresist on metal substrate such as aluminum or TiN is very important to develop lithography
process without BARC. The adhesion change between photoresist and metal substrate will be
changed as function of how we apply pretreatments for metal substrate. The typical
pretreatments before patterning are dry ash, wet cleaning and HMDS treatment.
In this paper, we study that adhesion changes as function of pretreatments and their
mechanism. To understand the interaction between photoresist and substrate, we analyze
surface change of wafers which prepared with several different experimental conditions using
XPS (X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy) and Dynamic Contact Angle Analyzer. The results will
explain how photoresist adhesion may be changed with different pretreatment conditions and
how we can optimize process condition to improve photoresist adhesion without BARC.
Rigorous modeling and analysis of impact produced by microstructures in mask on wafer pattern fidelity
Show abstract
As feature size continuously decreasing new techniques to improve quality of wafer are developed. Hence a lot of new
problems in semiconductor industry arise. Strict control of quality of wafer during production process is very important
as many factors can influence on it, but the main contribution gives scanner error and mask. Thus at least impact of mask
should be reduced.
In this work we apply rigorous model to predict impact of microstructures to pattern fidelity on wafer. Such
microstructures are commonly generated in quartz layer to control transmittance distribution on photomask. It is shown
that effect from microstructures is not only changing of mask transmittance but also distortion of the pattern fidelity on
wafer. Rigorous modeling gives us possibility to calculate aerial image and CD on wafer in case of presence of microstructures
in the quartz. We vary optical parameters, such as refractive indexes, number, size and location of these
elements in order to reduce the distortion of pattern fidelity on wafer.
Our result allows prediction of the impact of microstructures in photomask on wafer pattern fidelity instead of doing set
of experiments. Moreover, the best conditions for experiment are found and discussed.
The flash memory battle: How low can we go?
Show abstract
With the introduction of the TWINSCAN XT:1900Gi the limit of the water based hyper-NA immersion lithography has
been reached in terms of resolution. With a numerical aperture of 1.35 a single expose resolution of 36.5nm half pitch
has been demonstrated. However the practical resolution limit in production will be closer to 40nm half pitch, without
having to go to double patterning alike strategies. In the relentless Flash memory market the performance of the
exposure tool is stretched to the limit for a competitive advantage and cost-effective product.
In this paper we will present the results of an experimental study of the resolution limit of the NAND-Flash Memory
Gate layer for a production-worthy process on the TWINSCAN XT:1900Gi. The entire gate layer will be qualified in
terms of full wafer CD uniformity, aberration sensitivities for the different wordlines and feature-center placement
errors for 38, 39, 40 and 43nm half pitch design rule. In this study we will also compare the performance of a binary
intensity mask to a 6% attenuated phase shift mask and look at strategies to maximize Depth of Focus, and to desensitize
the gate layer for lens aberrations and placement errors. The mask is one of the dominant contributors to the
CD uniformity budget of the flash gate layer. Therefore the wafer measurements are compared to aerial image
measurements of the mask using AIMSTM 45-193i to separate the mask contribution from the scanner contribution to the
final imaging performance.
Measuring layer-specific depth-of-focus requirements
Show abstract
As the Rayleigh equations already tell us, improvements in imaging resolution often come at the price of a depth-offocus
loss. Often we balance the resolution versus DoF dilemma without regard of the imaging layers location in the
overall film stack. E.g. often several via or metal layers are processed with the same optical settings despite facing
different amount of depth-of-focus requirements.
In actuality, however, substrate induced focus variation can vary greatly from layers at the bottom of a film stack to the
layers higher up in the film stack. In the age of super-low k1 lithography this variance needs to be taken into account on a
layer specific basis when evaluating the resolution versus DoF tradeoff.
We have studied substrate induced focus variation for a 45nm technology test-site as function of film stack sequence and
spatial frequency, combining various measurement techniques into an overall topography spectrum. These techniques
include data extraction from the exposure tools optical leveling sensor, a mechanical air gauge to calibrate the former
and interferometric profiling tools.
As a result, we can quantify our DoF requirement for a given layer and product and use this information to optimize our
process design on a layer-by-layer basis.
This work was performed by the Research Alliance Teams at various IBM Research and Development
Facilities
Effects of laser bandwidth on tool to tool CD matching
Show abstract
According to the ITRS roadmap, low k1 imaging requires extremely tight control
of Critical Dimension (CD). Maintaining the same performance from one exposure to
another for new imaging requirements has become increasingly important, particularly
for matching dry and wet systems. Tool to tool CD matching depends on many factors,
for example, lens aberrations, partial coherence, laser spectral bandwidth and short range
flare.
We have performed a detailed study of laser bandwidth effects on tool CD matching for
typical 65nm node structures exposed on immersion ArF scanners. A high accuracy
on-board spectrometer was used to characterize the lithography
Laser bandwidth, allowing measurements of both the FWHM and E95 parameters of the
laser spectrum. Spectral bandwidth was adjusted over a larger range than normally
experienced during wafer exposures using Cymer's Tunable Advanced Bandwidth
Stabilization device (T-ABS) to provide controlled changes in bandwidth while
maintaining all other laser performance parameters within specification.
Measurements of both Lines and Contact Holes on 65nm node structures through all
pitches were made and correlated with bandwidth to determine the sensitivity of IDB and
C/H to bandwidth variation. We demonstrated that bandwidth can be adjusted for CD
matching on different tool using the T-ABS function.
Improving lithography intra wafer CD for C045 implant layers using STI thickness feed forward?
Show abstract
In this paper we performed an analysis of various data collection preformed on C045 production lots in order to
assess the influence of STI oxide layers on the CD uniformity of implant photolithography layers. Our final purpose is to
show whether the DOSE MAPPERTM software option for interfiled dose correction available on ASML scanners
combined with a run-to-run feed-forward regulation loop could improve global CD uniformity on C045 implants layers.
After a brief presentation of the C045 implants context the results of the analysis are presented : swing curves, process
windows analysis, and intra-die CD measurements are presented. The conclusion of the analysis is that it is not possible,
in the current C045 industrial environment, to use a robust and general method of interfield dose correction in order to
achieve a better global CD uniformity.
More on practical solutions to eliminate reticle haze and extend reticle life in the production environment: specially designed RSPs, internal POD purifiers, and XCDA purged reticle stockers
William Goodwin,
Matt Welch,
Bruce Laquidara,
et al.
Show abstract
Use of specially designed reticle SMIF pods (RSPs) - with unique purge flow, internal dual-capture mechanism
purifiers and an ultra-low humidity CDA purging system- have provided a practical solution to eliminate reticle haze
for the useful life of the reticle in production environments. Prior publications, Kishkovich et al., described newly
understood mechanisms of reticle haze formation based on chemical modification of quartz and chrome surfaces and
have proposed solutions based on continual purge of the reticle environment with ultra-low humidity purified air [1]. In
further publications they reported successful application of this solution in the field on single reticle-pod purge systems.
[2]
In this paper we provide guidance and advice for high volume manufacturing haze control practitioners, describing some
challenges and solutions implemented on reticle stocker equipment, including considerations for materials of
construction, purge flow levels and regulation, in-pod moisture/chemical purifiers, and on-tool flow measurement
techniques.
Monitoring defects at wafer’s edge for improved immersion lithography performance
Show abstract
The immersion fluid in the lens - wafer gap of advanced lithography scanners has the propensity to be a transport media
for imaging defects. A great deal of effort has been devoted to understanding and eliminating the root causes of
patterned defects in immersion lithography. Characterization of patterned and unpatterned defects on the wafer top
surface has helped to drive improvements in lithography equipment, processes and materials design that subsequently
enabled immersion defect density levels to be commensurate with dry lithography. This has enabled the insertion of
immersion lithography into mainstream manufacturing. However, the "ever improving" yield impetus drives the need to
search for and eliminate defect sources beyond the conventional top surface. This paper describes progress in extending
these efforts to and beyond the wafer's edge.
Modeling the work piece charging during e-beam lithography
Show abstract
Nowadays, high end photomasks are usually patterned with electron beam writers since they provide a superior
resolution. However, placement accuracy is severely limited by the so-called charging effect: Each shot with the
electron beam deposits charges inside the mask blank which deflect the electrons in the subsequent shots and
therefore cause placement errors. In this paper, a model is proposed which allows to establish a prediction of
the deflection of the beam and thus provide a method for improving pattern placement for photomasks.
SEM-contour based mask modeling
Show abstract
With the push toward the 32nm node, OPC modeling must respond in kind with additional accuracy enhancements.
One area of lithographic modeling that has basically gone unchecked is mask fidelity. Mask linearity is typically built
into the OPC model since the calibration data contain this information, but mask pattern fidelity is almost impossible to
quantify for OPC modeling. Mask fidelity is the rounding and smoothing of the mask features relative to the post-OPC
layout intent, and there is no robust metric available to quantify these effects. With the introduction of contour-based
model calibration, mask fidelity modeling is possible. This work evaluates techniques to quantify mask modeling and
methods to gauge the accuracy improvement that mask fidelity modeling would project into the lithographic process
using contour-based mask model calibration.
Integration of high-speed surface-channel charge coupled devices into an SOI CMOS process using strong phase shift lithography
Show abstract
To enable development of novel signal processing circuits, a high-speed surface-channel charge
coupled device (CCD) process has been co-integrated with the Lincoln Laboratory 180-nm RF fully depleted
silicon-on-insulator (FDSOI) CMOS technology. The CCDs support charge transfer clock speeds in excess of
1 GHz while maintaining high charge transfer efficiency (CTE). Both the CCD and CMOS gates are formed
using a single-poly process, with CCD gates isolated by a narrow phase-shift-defined gap. CTE is strongly
dependent on tight control of the gap critical dimension (CD).
In this paper we review the tradeoffs encountered in the co-integration of the CCD and CMOS
technologies. The effect of partial coherence on gap resolution and pattern fidelity is discussed. The impact of
asymmetric bias due to phase error and phase shift mask (PSM) sidewall effects is presented, along with
adopted mitigation strategies. Issues relating to CMOS pattern fidelity and CD control in the double patterning
process are also discussed.
Since some signal processing CCD structures involve two-dimensional transfer paths, many required
geometries present phase compliance and trim engineering challenges. Approaches for implementing non-compliant
geometries, such as T shapes, are described, and the impact of various techniques on electrical
performance is discussed.
32 nm 1:1 line and space patterning by resist reflow process
Show abstract
Making a sub-32 nm line and space pattern is the most important issue in semiconductor process. Specially, it
is important to make line and space pattern when the device type is NAND flash memory because the unit cell is mostly
composed of line and space pattern. Double patterning method is regarded as the most promising technology for sub-32
nm half-pitch node. However, double patterning method is expensive for the production and heavy data split is required.
In order to make cheaper and easier patterning, we suggest a resist reflow process (RRP) method for 32 nm 1:1 line and
space pattern. It is easier to make 1:3 pitch than 1:1 pitch line and space in terms of aerial image, and RRP can make 1:3
pitch aerial image to 1:1 resist image. We used home-made RRP simulation based on Navier-Stokes equation including
surface tension effect. Solid-E is used for optical simulation, and e-beam lithography is used for the experiment to check
the concept.
Optimum dose variation caused by post exposure bake temperature difference inside photoresist over different sublayers and thickness
Show abstract
In principle, the dose should not be changed to make the same linewidth if a perfect anti-reflection coating (ARC) is
used for all the sublayers underneath the resist. However, the optimum dose for different sublayers and thicknesses are
different even though perfect ARC is used. The post exposure bake (PEB) process of a chemically amplified resist is one
of the key processes to make very small features of semiconductor device. The photo-generated acid makes the
deprotection of protected polymer, and this deprotection highly depends on the PEB temperature and time. The diffusion
length of acid is also strongly dependent on PEB temperature and time. As the linewidth of the device decreases, smaller
diffusion length is required to reduce the roughness of the line edge and width.
One of the key factors to determine the deprotection and acid diffusion is the initial temperature rising and the final real
temperature inside the resist. The unpredictable temperature rising to the pre-set temperature mainly causes the variation
of linewidth and the optimum dose. In order to predict the accurate PEB temperature and time dependency of the
linewidth and dose, the heat transfer from the hot plate to the resist on the top of the multiply stacked sublayers over the
silicon wafer has to be known since the reaction and diffusion occur inside the resist, not on the top of the bare silicon
wafer. We studied heat transfer from the hot plate to the top of the resist including conductivity and thickness of each sublayer.
For this purpose, a novel numerical approach incorporated with analytic method was proposed to solve the heat
conduction problem. The unknowns for temperature are located only at the interfaces between layers, so that it is fast and
efficient. We calculated the time that is consumed for the resist to attain the prescribed PEB temperature for the different
multi stacks and thicknesses. Calculation shows that the temperature rising is different and final temperature on top of the resist is also different for
various sublayers and thicknesses of theirs including resist itself. Experiment by us and others also clearly show that
there is a definite temperature difference between on top of the bare wafer and on top of the resist. The effects for the
different layer stacks and thicknesses are investigated to obtain proper dose and linewidth control due to different actual
resist PEB temperature.
The analysis of optical lithography at 2-dimensional dense structure
Show abstract
New concepts about transistor structure are being introduced for sub-50nm memory products. As the memory cell
design is shrinking down, conventional transistor of planar structure can not guarantee safe transistor operation.
Newly introduced transistor has to ensure robust transistor operation characteristics and process stability
simultaneously. One of the candidates which are being developed recently is vertical transistor. The basic layout to
integrate vertical transistor include very dense 2-dimensional features. The new memory cell based on dense structure
can also contribute to reduction of cell area compared to conventional memory cell such as 8F2 planar cell. While new
memory structure enables the reduction of chip size, its 2-dimensional structure limits resolving performance of optical
lithography inevitably. It is very challenging to build 4F2 dense features of sub-50nm node by single exposure
technology using hyper NA ArF lithography before the EUV era. In this paper, the feasibility of 2-dimensional dense
structure at 50nm node is presented and various techniques are introduced to realize new memory scheme as next
generation memory cell structure.
Image contrast contributions to immersion lithography defect formation and process yield
Show abstract
As the industry extends immersion lithography to the 32 nm node, the limits of image and resist contrast will be
challenged. Image contrast is limited by the inherent numerical aperture of a water based immersion lithography system.
Elements of resist design and processing can further degrade the final deprotected image contrast1,2. Studies have been
done to understand the effects of image contrast on line width roughness (LER) for dry 193 nm lithography3. This paper
focuses on the impacts of image and resist contrast on the formation of defects and LER in an immersion lithography
process.
Optical and resist simulations are combined with experiments to better understand the relationship between image
quality, resist design, scanner/track processing and defect formation. The goal of this work is to develop a relationship
between resist contrast metrics and defect formation for immersion processes.
Demonstration of production readiness of an immersion lithography cell
Alberto Beccalli,
Paolo Canestrari,
Mark Goeke,
et al.
Show abstract
This paper describes the qualification work performed on a state-of-the-art immersion cluster and shows results for an
immersion process for the 45nm node. These results demonstrate full compliance with all lithographic parameters,
including CD control and defectivity. Qualification was performed on an RF3iTM wafer track from Sokudo Co., Ltd. and
a 1.2NA immersion scanner. A three-layer material stack was engineered using 820Å BARC / 1800Å ArF photoresist
covered by 900Å immersion top-coat.
After verification of tool and process cleanliness and testing the robustness of the material stack for use in the immersion
scanner, resulting photo cell monitor (PCM) defect density on a 65nm memory device was evaluated.
Critical dimension was verified using both CD-SEM and optical CD metrology. Results on a 45nm L/S pattern showed
0.55nm WIW 3sigma CD uniformity using optical CD metrology. Lot to lot CD control was tested for being below
1.5nm 3sigma. As special Soak-units were used prior to post exposure bake (PEB), the influence of post exposure delay
(PED) on the CD performance was studied and quantified.
All immersion-related modules were optimized and qualified on both 65nm products and 45nm prototypes. Additionally,
comparison data for immersion and dry lithography will be presented.
Poster Session: Simulation
High-speed microlithography aerial image simulation without four-dimensional singular-value decomposition
Show abstract
The traditional Hopkins based microlithography aerial image simulation methods most likely require expensive
4D Singular Value Decomposition operations to obtain mutually incoherent kernels. This is often a problem when
the requirement of resolution is high especially when sub-resolution assist features are present. During the process
development and model fitting, kernels are required to generate frequently. In this paper, we demonstrate that it
is not necessary to perform this expensive task to generate those kernels. By taking advantage of several classical
matrix theories, we are able to directly extract kernels without resorting to 4D Singular Value Decomposition
operations. The accuracy and efficiency will be extensively studied in the experimental results.
Coupled eigenmode theory applied to thick mask modeling of TM polarized imaging
Show abstract
Coupled eigenmode (CEM) theory for TM polarized illumination is presented and applied to the 3D modeling of a linespace
reticle. In this approach, the electric and magnetic field inside a line-space reticle is described in terms of an
orthogonal set of eigenmodes of Maxwell's equations. The diffraction of light by the reticle can then be expressed as a
coherent sum of diffraction orders produced by each eigenmode independently. Fresnel transmission, overlap of
eigenmodes with diffraction orders and propagation through the mask are shown to be the interactions that determine the
complex amplitude of the diffraction orders produced by each mode. We further shown that only a small number of
eigenmodes are needed to accurately calculate image contrast under TM polarized illumination.
A rigorous finite-element domain decomposition method for electromagnetic near field simulations
Show abstract
Rigorous computer simulations of propagating electromagnetic fields have become an important tool for optical
metrology and design of nanostructured optical components. A vectorial finite element method (FEM) is a good
choice for an accurate modeling of complicated geometrical features. However, from a numerical point of view
solving the arising system of linear equations is very demanding even for medium sized 3D domains. In numerics,
a domain decomposition method is a commonly used strategy to overcome this problem. Within this approach
the overall computational domain is split up into smaller domains and interface conditions are used to assure
continuity of the electromagnetic field. Unfortunately, standard implementations of the domain decomposition
method as developed for electrostatic problems are not appropriate for wave propagation problems. In an earlier
paper we therefore proposed a domain decomposition method adapted to electromagnetic field wave propagation
problems. In this paper we apply this method to 3D mask simulation.
Influence of pellicle on hyper-NA imaging
Show abstract
In the case of hyper-NA (NA>1) imaging with the lens magnification keeping 1/4, the angle
of light incidence on pellicle becomes bigger. For example, it is up to 19 degrees for NA=1.3 lens. It
is already known that the effect of multiple reflections of the light inside the pellicle film becomes
obvious, in that the effect contains transmission variation across the light incidence angle on the
pellicle. For normal pellicle, transmission of oblique incidence light is lower than the normal
incidence light and the difference is about 10% as intensity changes. And pellicle thickness error
affects the transmission characteristics. Thus, pellicle thickness error causes change of iso-dense
bias (or optical proximity effect; OPE) and dense line CD variation.
Specs for CD uniformity in below half pitch (hp) 45nm imaging become tighter, and
therefore, pellicle should not be a new root cause of CD error. The solutions for the issue are (1)
tighter specs for pellicle thickness or (2) selection of optimal pellicle thickness. The latter is more
effective for suppressing CD variation across the exposure field than the former.
In our paper, we describe the pellicle effect for through-pitch imaging including below hp45
nm dense L/S using hyper-NA lens. We discuss pellicle thickness optimization for better CD
uniformity and the results of simulation for some pellicle conditions.
Rigorous electromagnetic field simulation of two-beam interference exposures for the exploration of double patterning and double exposure scenarios
Show abstract
The introduction of double patterning and double exposure technologies, especially in combination with hyper NA,
increases the importance of wafer topography phenomena. Rigorous electromagnetic field (EMF) simulations of two
beam interference exposures over non-planar wafers are used to explore the impact of the hardmask material and pattern
on resulting linewidths and swing curves after the second lithography step. Moreover, the impact of the optical material
contrast between the frozen and unfrozen resist in a pattern freezing process and the effect of a reversible contrast enhancement
layer on the superposition of two subsequent lithographic exposures are simulated. The described simulation
approaches can be used for the optimization of wafer stack configurations for double patterning and to identify appropriate
optical material properties for alternative double patterning and double exposure techniques.
A simulation study on the impact of lithographic process variations on CMOS device performance
Show abstract
In this paper, we demonstrate how a direct coupling of a lithography simulation program and a semiconductor
device simulation tool can be used to investigate the impact of lithographic process variations on nano-scaled
CMOS devices. In contrast to conventional evaluation criteria such as process windows, mask error enhancement
factor (MEEF), or CD (critical dimension) uniformity, the lithography process is regarded in a more holistic
fashion as a means to an end. As a consequence, the ultimate figure of merit is determined by the performance
of the device.
Lithography simulations are conducted using a rigorous EMF solver for the computation of the mask nearfield.
TCAD process and device simulations are performed for an ultra thinned body fully depleted silicon on insulator
(UTB FD-SOI) nMOSFET, with a physical gate length of 32 nm. Electrical parameters such as on- and off-
current, threshold voltage, sub-threshold slope, gate-capacitance, and contact resistances are computed and
extracted. The impact of lithographic process variations on the electrical behavior of the target device is surveyed
and illustrated. Moreover, we present an adjusted lithography process window defined by the electrical behavior
of the device.
In addition to a discussion of the obtained results, this paper also focuses on the software design aspects of
interfacing a lithography simulation environment with a device simulator. The steps involved in extracting parameters
and transferring them from one program to the other are explained, and further automation capabilities
are suggested. Moreover, it is illustrated how this approach can be extended towards an integrated litho/device
process optimization procedure.